The Geneva Protocol — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Geneva Protocol
John Stuart Mill · en
Upon these various texts, separate reports were submitted, which, being
approved by the Committees respectively responsible for them, may be
considered as an official commentary by the Committees.
These separate reports have here been combined in order to present as a
whole the work accomplished by the two Committees and to facilitate
explanation.
Before entering upon an analysis of the proposed texts, it is expedient
to recall, in a brief historical summary, the efforts of the last four
years, of which the texts are the logical conclusion.
HISTORICAL STATEMENT.
The problem of the reduction of armaments is presented in Article 8 of
the Covenant in terms which reveal at the outset the complexity of the
question and which explain the tentative manner in which the subject
has been treated by the League of Nations in the last few years.
"The Members of the League recognise that the maintenance
of peace requires the reduction of national armaments to
{159}
the lowest point consistent with national safety and the
enforcement by common action of international obligations."
Here we see clearly expressed the need of reducing the burden which
armaments imposed upon the nations immediately after the war and of
putting a stop to the competition in armaments which was, in itself, a
threat to the peace of the world. But, at the same time, there is
recognised the duty of safeguarding the national security of the
Members of the League and of safeguarding it, not only by the
maintenance of a necessary minimum of troops, but also by the
co-operation of all the nations, by a vast organisation for peace.
Such is the meaning of the Covenant, which, while providing for
reduction of armaments properly so called, recognises at the same time
the need of _common action_, by all the Members of the League, with a
view to compelling a possible disturber of the peace to respect his
_international obligations_.
Thus, in this first paragraph of Article 8, which is so short but so
pregnant, mention is made of all the problems which have engaged the
attention of our predecessors and ourselves and which the present
Assembly has specially instructed us to solve, the problems of
_collective security_ and the _reduction of armaments_.
Taking up Article 8 of the Covenant, the First Assembly had already
outlined a programme. At its head it placed a pronouncement of the
Supreme Council:
"In order to diminish the economic difficulties of Europe,
armies should everywhere be reduced to a peace footing.
Armaments should be limited to the lowest possible figure
compatible with national security."
The Assembly also called attention to a resolution of the International
Financial Conference of Brussels held a short time before: