The Geneva Protocol — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Geneva Protocol
John Stuart Mill · en
The First Assembly of the League of Nations in 1920 prepared to give
effect to article 8 of the Covenant, the first two paragraphs of which
read: "The Members of the League recognise that the maintenance of
peace requires the reduction of national armaments to the lowest point
consistent with national safety and the enforcement by common action of
International obligations. The Council .......... shall formulate
plans for such reduction for the consideration and action of the
several Governments." That Assembly decided "to instruct a Temporary
Commission to prepare reports and proposals for the reduction of
armaments as provided for by article 8 of the Covenant." In the
following year the Second Assembly defined the task more clearly in a
resolution instructing the Temporary Mixed Commission to make proposals
for the reduction of armaments which, in order to secure precision,
"should be in the form of a draft Treaty or other equally defined plan,
to be presented to the Council, if possible, before the Assembly next
year" (1922). In the course of the ensuing year the Temporary Mixed
Commission was able to formulate certain principles which, in its
opinion, might serve as a basis for the draft Treaty which it had been
instructed to draw up. After discussion of these principles the Third
Assembly passed a resolution--the famous {218} Resolution
14--recognising that in existing circumstances many Governments would
be unable to accept responsibility for a serious reduction of armaments
unless they received in exchange a satisfactory guarantee of the safety
of their country, and suggesting that such guarantee could be found in
a defensive agreement binding them to provide immediate and effective
assistance, in accordance with a pre-arranged plan, in the event of one
of them being attacked. The Temporary Mixed Commission were instructed
to prepare a draft Treaty on these lines. The result of their labours
was submitted to the Fourth Assembly last year in the form of the Draft
Treaty of Mutual Assistance, which was referred by the Assembly to the
Governments for their observations.
2. Certain Governments accepted the draft Treaty in principle: very few
intimated their readiness to adhere to its actual terms. His Majesty's
Government, in a note which has already been made public,[1] explained
the reasons which would render it impossible for them to subscribe to
the Treaty.
3. When, therefore, the Fifth Assembly met on the 1st September of this
year, the labours of four years, which had been devoted to the
preparation of a scheme for giving effect to the obligation undertaken
by all signatories in article 8 of the Covenant, had not succeeded in
establishing agreement, and there seemed no prospect of making any
further advance along the path which had hitherto been followed.
4. Some new direction would have to be given, and the presence in
Geneva of the British and French Prime Ministers gave a special
importance to the meeting.