The Dublin Corporation, at the period, was considered as the stronghold
of the Protestant ascendancy, and the hostility to what were called the
Catholic claims was carried to great excess. Mr. O’Connell, the champion
of his party, assumed a tone equally violent and acrimonious; and at a
meeting of the Catholics, held in Dublin, spoke of the corporation of
that city in the most contemptuous terms, and amongst other abusive
epithets, called it “a beggarly corporation,” an expression which soon
became a by-word with their opponents.
Mr. D’Esterre, a young man of great respectability and high spirit, felt
indignant at the reproach cast upon the body of which he was a member;
and there is reason to believe that his indignation was fanned by the
instigation of his colleagues, who were anxious to rid themselves of
such a formidable opponent as O’Connell. D’Esterre, therefore, addressed
a letter to O’Connell, to know whether he had used the expression which
the public papers attributed to him. O’Connell, in reply, neither
admitted nor disclaimed the alleged charge, but stated that no terms,
however reproachful, could exceed the contemptuous feelings he
entertained for the corporation as a public body. To this he added, that
his letter must close all correspondence on the subject. Mr. D’Esterre
was advised to address another letter to Mr. O’Connell, which was
returned unread, by that gentleman’s brother. Various reports were now
circulated, and it was stated that D’Esterre intended to offer O’Connell
personal violence, should he meet him in the streets. Thus did a week
pass, during which threats and violent language were exchanged between
the two hostile parties; and it was generally concluded that a duel
could not be avoided. Mr. George Lidwell, at Mr. O’Connell’s request,
had waited a few days in Dublin expecting a message from Mr. D’Esterre,
and at length Sir Edward Stanley, Barrack-master of Dublin, and a friend
of Mr. D’Esterre, waited on O’Connell with the hostile message so long
expected. The challenge was accepted, and the necessary arrangements
were made between Major Macnamara and Sir E. Stanley.
The parties met at Bishop’s Court demesne, Lord Ponsonby’s seat, in the
county Kildare, thirteen miles from Dublin. It is said that in the
meeting Mr. D’Esterre had been very disadvantageously placed by his
second, being in a line with a tree, which afforded direction to his
adversary’s aim.
BETWEEN COLONEL QUENTIN AND COLONEL PALMER.
February 9, 1815.