The Life of Napoleon Bonaparte. Vol. 4 (of 4) — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Life of Napoleon Bonaparte. Vol. 4 (of 4)
John Stuart Mill · en
In actual captivity his mind was without a sufficient task and under
no pressure from necessity. It consequently, though somewhat
invigorated at first, intermitted more and more toward the close,
working, when it did work, awkwardly and with friction, until the
physical collapse came, and the end was reached. The attempts to
remodel history, the efforts to delineate his own and others' motives,
the specious summaries of his career and its epochs, the fragmentary
expositions of his philosophy in ethics, politics, and psychology--all
the stately volumes which bear his name, his literary remains, in
fact, present a pitiful sight when closely examined. They are but the
scoriae of a burnt-out mind, but dust and ashes; a splendid mass, but
an extinct volcano. It was only natural that his successors and
admirers should seek to erect a more enduring foundation for his fame
by collecting and carefully editing what he had written when at his
best, when acting according to his momentary, normal impulse, and
when, therefore, he had the least pose and the greatest sincerity. But
it is a proof of their shrewdness that they selected and published
less and less after Erfurt, and that out of the voluminous pen-product
of St. Helena they chose a hundred and fifty pages which the
"Correspondence," intended to be the most splendid monument to the
Emperor's glory, could present as authentic biographical material.
If, then, Napoleon was after all but a plain man, how did he become a
personage? Simply because he was the typical man of his day, less the
personal mediocrity; the typical burgher in personal character, the
typical soldier in war, the typical despot in peace, and the typical
idealist in politics; capable in all these qualities of analysis;
capable, consequently, of being understood; capable of exhaustion and
of being overwhelmed by combinations. In other words, he was really
great because he was the shrewd common-sense personage of his age,
considering the ideal social structure as a level of comfort in money,
in shelter, in food, in clothes, in religion, in morality, in decency,
in domestic good-nature, in the commonplace good things fairly divided
as far as they would go round. This was the side of his nature which
in a period of social exhaustion planted him four-square as a social
force, presented him to France as the rock against which the "red
fool-fury" of Jacobinism had dashed itself to pieces, and gave him for
a time command of all hearts. Thus established, he at once fell heir
to French tradition--that is, to the continuous policy of the nation
in foreign and domestic affairs; which was that France should be the
Jupiter in the Olympus of European nations by reason of her excellence
both in beauty and in strength. Here was a temptation not to be
resisted, the superlative temptation like that of the serpent and the
woman, the chance to transcend by knowledge, the opportunity to "hitch