The Old Red Sandstone; or, New Walks in an Old Field
John Stuart Mill · en
[Footnote BB: I have heard elderly fishermen of the Moray Frith
state, in connection with what they used to term "the haddock dearth"
of this period, that, for several weeks ere the fish entirely
disappeared, they acquired an extremely disagreeable taste, as if
they had been boiled in tobacco juice, and became unfit for the
table. For the three following years they were extremely rare on the
coast, and several years more elapsed ere they were caught in the
usual abundance. The fact related by Creech, a very curious one, I
subjoin in his own words; it occurs in his third _Letter to Sir John
Sinclair_: "On Friday, the 4th December, 1789, the ship _Brothers_,
Captain Stewart, arrived at Leith from Archangel, who reported that,
on the coast of Lapland and Norway, he sailed many leagues through
immense quantities of dead haddocks floating on the sea. He spoke
several English ships, who reported the same fact. It is certain
that haddocks, which was the fish in the greatest abundance in the
Edinburgh market, have scarcely been seen there these three years. In
February, 1790, three haddocks were brought to market, which, from
their scarcity, sold for 7s. 6d."
The dead haddocks seen by the Leith shipmaster were floating by
thousands; and most of their congeners among what fishermen term
"the white fish," such as cod, ling, and whiting, also float when
dead; whereas the bodies of fish whose bowels and air-bladders are
comparatively small and tender, lie at the bottom. The herring
fisherman, if the fish die in his nets, finds it no easy matter to
buoy them up; and if the shoal entangled be a large one, he fails at
times, from the great weight, in recovering them at all, losing both
nets and herrings. Now, if a corresponding difference obtained among
fish of the extinct period--if some rose to the surface when they
died, while others remained at the bottom--we must, of course, expect
to find their remains in very different degrees of preservation--to
find only scattered fragments of the floaters, while of the others
many may occur comparatively entire. Even should they have died
on the same beds, too, we may discover their remains separated by
hundreds of miles. The haddocks that disappeared from the coast of
Britain were found floating in shoals on the coasts of Norway. The
remains of an immense body of herrings, that weighed down, a few
seasons since, the nets of a crew of fishermen, in a muddy hollow
of the Moray Frith, and defied the utmost exertions of three crews
united to weigh them from the bottom, are, I doubt not, in the
muddy hollow still. On a principle thus obvious it may be deemed
not improbable that the ichthyolites of the Lower Old Red Sandstone
might have had numerous contemporaries, of which, unless in some
instances the same accident which killed also entombed them, we can
know nothing in their character as such, and whose broken fragments
may yet be found in some other locality, where they may be regarded