The People's Common Sense Medical Adviser in Plain English: or, Medicine Simplified, 54th ed., One Million, Six Hundred; and Fifty Thousand
John Stuart Mill · en
Although proteid matter is the essential element of food, and under
certain circumstances may be sufficient of itself to support the body,
it is a very uneconomical food. The white of an egg, which may be taken
as a type of the proteids, contains about fifteen per cent. of nitrogen,
and fifty-three per cent. of carbon; therefore, a man feeding upon this,
would take in about three and a half times as much carbon as nitrogen.
It has been proved that a healthy, adult man, taking a fair amount of
exercise and maintaining his weight and body temperature, eliminates
about thirteen times as much carbon as nitrogen. However, if he is to
get his necessary quantity, about 4000 grains of carbon, out of albumen,
he must eat 7,547 grains of that substance; but this quantity of albumen
contains nearly four times as much nitrogen as he requires. In other
words, it takes about four pounds of lean meat, free from fat, to
furnish 4,000 grains of carbon, the quantity required, whereas one pound
yields the requisite quantity of nitrogen. Thus a man restricted
exclusively to a proteid diet, must take an enormous quantity of it.
This would involve a large amount of unnecessary physiological labor, to
comminute, dissolve, and absorb the food, and to excrete the superfluous
nitrogenous matter. Unproductive labor should be avoided as much in
physiological as in political economy. The universal practice of
subsisting on a mixed diet, in which proteids are mixed with fats or
amyloids, is therefore justifiable.
Fats contain about 80 per cent. of carbon, and amyloids about 40 per
cent. We have seen that there is sufficient nitrogen in a pound of meat
free from fat, to supply a healthy adult man for twenty-four hours, but
that it contains only one-fourth of the quantity of carbon required.
About half a pound of fat, or one pound of sugar, will supply the
quantity of carbon necessary. The fat, if properly subdivided, and the
sugar, by reason of its solubility, pass with great ease into the
circulation, the physiological labor, consequently, being reduced to a
minimum.
Several common articles of diet contain in themselves all the necessary
elements. Thus, butchers' meat ordinarily contains from 30 to 50 per
cent. of fat; and bread contains the proteid, gluten, and the amyloids,
starch and sugar, together with minute quantities of fat. However, on
account of the proportion in which these proteid and other components of
the body exist in these substances, neither of them, by itself is such a
physiologically economical food, as it is when combined with the other
in the proportion of three to eight, or three quarters of a pound of
meat to two pounds of bread a day.