The Plébiscite; or, A Miller's Story of the War: By One of the 7,500,000 Who Voted "Yes" — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Plébiscite; or, A Miller's Story of the War: By One of the 7,500,000 Who Voted "Yes"
John Stuart Mill · en
Next day we learned that two Landwehr had been found killed--one near
the Avenue des Dames, between the town and the Quatre Vents, the other
at the end of Piquet, both fathers of families. The unfortunate men
had been surprised at their posts.
What a miserable thing is war! The Germans have lost more men than we
have; but we will not be so cruel as to rejoice over this.
And now, if I am asked my opinion about the Turcos, against whom the
Germans have raised such an outcry, I answer that they are good men and
true! Jacob and Jean Baptiste have received everything that we sent to
them. This Turco's word was worth more than that of the lieutenant and
the feld-weibel who had promised to pay me for my wine.
No doubt, amongst the Turcos there are some bad fellows; but the
greater part are honest men, with a strong feeling of religion: men who
have known them at Phalsbourg and elsewhere acknowledge them to be men
of honor. They have stolen nothing, robbed nobody, never insulted a
woman. If they had campaigned on the other side of the Rhine, of
course they would have twisted the necks of ducks and hens, as all
soldiers do in an enemy's country: the Landwehr put no constraint upon
themselves in our country. But the idea would never have occurred to
the Turcos, as it had to German officers and generals, of sending for
packs of Jews to follow them and buy up, wholesale, the linen,
furniture, clocks--in a word, anything they found in private
individuals' houses. This is simple truth! Monsieur de Bismarck may
insult the Turcos as much as he pleases before his German Parliament,
which is ready to say "Amen" every time he opens his mouth. He might
as well not talk at all. Thieves are bad judges of common honesty! I
am aware that Monsieur le Prince de Bismarck thinks himself the first
politician in the world, because he has deceived a simpleton; but there
is a wide difference between a great man and a great dishonest man. By
and by this will be manifest, to the great misfortune of Europe.
But it was a real comfort to have seen this Turco; and for several
days, when we were alone, my wife and Gredel talked of nothing else;
but sad reflections again got the upper hand.
No one can form an idea of the misery, the feeling of desolation which
takes possession of you, when days and weeks pass by in the midst of
enemies without the least word reaching you from the interior; then you
feel the strength of the hold that your native land has upon you. The
Germans think to detach us from it by preventing us from learning what
is taking place there; but they are mistaken. The less you speak the
more you think; and your indignation, your disgust, your hatred for
violence, force, and injustice is ever on the increase. You conceive a
horror for those who have been the cause of such sufferings. Time
brings no change; on the contrary, it deepens the wound: one curse
succeeds another; and the deepest desire left is either for an end of
all, or vengeance.