The Shadow of the Past — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Shadow of the Past
John Stuart Mill · en
"Oh, Empire building!" she said indifferently. "What of the human need?
... Isn't that more important? You are overlooking that, and yet it's
the most important thing of all. I don't think so much of the Empire.
Of course I'm patriotic; but the human need comes first."
He did not answer immediately. He looked into her eyes, puzzled and
disquieted, and reflected a while. The patriotism that Honor had
stirred into active being was questioned and opposed by this other
girl's quiet insistence on the claim of the individual. Was he in
danger of developing into a bloodless idealist, with a limited
understanding of the requirement both of the individual and of the
State?
So many emotions had held him of late for a space, so many thoughts had
filtered through his brain and left their conflicting impressions there,
that a certain confusion held possession of his mind. All the old warm
impulses were subdued and dulled, and he had nothing in the place of
them that was as good as the emotions he repressed. He realised that
now. Something--something enveloping, stultifying and bewildering the
understanding--dropped away from his soul, as a leaf drops from the tree
which no longer nourishes it. He saw clearly how surely, through
disappointment, he was drifting towards a hard callousness that would
end inevitably in all the kindly human sensibilities becoming submerged
therein and ultimately lost. He did not want that to happen. And yet
he felt that he had no power to stay this drifting. The warm, generous
youth of him was running back, as the sap runs back in the bark; and he
was no more able to prevent this than the tree to stay the processes of
nature. He had believed that he had discovered the purpose of life: now
he was beginning to realise that he had discovered nothing, only lost
something of worth, which he might never recover.
"It's odd," he remarked, "how you set me thinking. I never met any one
who challenged thought as you do. I believed I was on the right tack,
and you immediately point out that I've got my values wrong. It's like
having one's sums crossed out on the slate when one fancied the answers
were correct. There's a baffling sort of feeling about it. And you're
right, that's the worst of it."
"It's only your values that are wrong," she said quietly. "If you
readjust those, then the idea is fine enough."
In confiding his plans to her he had intended to prepare her for the
proposal of marriage he had in contemplation, and to accustom her to the
idea of marriage with a man who could never be a lover. He did not know
whether she divined his purpose, but he apprehended very clearly that
she would not be satisfied with that.
CHAPTER TWENTY FOUR.