The trap : $b Pilgrimage, Volume 8 — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The trap : $b Pilgrimage, Volume 8
John Stuart Mill · en
“Peace. Yes. But the staggering thing about all these men, the Hamlets
and the Schopenhauers, is that they don’t notice that people are
_miserable_ about being miserable. And uncomfortable, in varying
degrees, in wrong-doing. When they make up their philosophies of life
they leave out _themselves_. Like the people who talk of the vastness of
space and the ant-like smallness of humanity. If _one_ man, say
Schopenhauer, _sees_ quite clearly all the misery of life, and that it
ends, for everybody, in disease and pain and death, then there is
something in mankind that is not corruption.
“Then again all these thought-system people must have an illogical as
well as a logical side. A side where they don’t believe their own
systems. If they quite believed, instead of making a living out of their
bitterness they would make an end of _themselves_. But you know it’s
popular. There are lots of people who revel in it. Men particularly. It
makes them feel superior.
“And there’s another thing in these people. By the way they generally
have long _thin_ noses. Perhaps they don’t breathe properly. But the
great thing is that you must consider life _obscene_. You must look at
it from the outside, as shapes, helplessly writhing in the dark. If you
_see_ all this, and Schopenhauer did, you grin and snort and stand aside.
Women, he proves, don’t see it. And so they _are_ obscenity, blind
servants of obscenity, forever.”
“Horrible. Horrible.”
“That doesn’t matter. It isn’t true. It’s words. Nothing can ever be
expressed in words.”
CHAPTER V
1
Every friend to tea at the club is an event. Never-to-be-forgotten. What
each one says is written in my memory. And all of them are more real
there than on their own backgrounds. Simpler.
They are overwhelming, bringing both life and themselves; at large.
Shining; so that I want not to talk to them, but to keep them there in
place and contemplate them.
But for them it is dull. Perhaps embarrassing. They find me
empty-minded, distraite. And do not know why I am distraite. When they
go, there is no reason for asking them to come again, but my desire to
contemplate them.
Except Mrs. Orly.
Every moment in her presence is realisation. She babbles.... Has no
ideas. No self. Knows nothing about anyone. But redeems everyone.... God
can’t be worse than Mrs. Orly. And if she were on the judgment-seat,
everyone would be recklessly forgiven. With a flushed little face and
flashing eyes she would spank. Flare and scold. And then, pitiful
helping hands. Unscrupulously covering.
Having no self, she brings everyone a rich sense of self.
Most people, all the time, in every relationship, seek only themselves.
Past selves, if they are old....