The Women's Victory—and After: Personal Reminiscences, 1911-1918
John Stuart Mill · en
"Now, my Lords, I ask you to contemplate what may happen if, over
this matter, we come into collision with the House of Commons....
Your Lordships may vote as you please. You can cut this clause out of
the Bill. You have a perfect right to do so. But if you think that
by killing the clause you can also save the Bill, I believe you to
be mistaken. Nothing, to my mind, is more certain ... than that, if
your Lordships cut this clause out of the Bill, as you may perhaps be
going to do, the House of Commons will return the Bill to you with
the clause reinserted. Will you be prepared to put it back? Will you
be content, if you eliminate the clause, with this vigorous protest
you have made, and will you then be prepared to give way? Or, if you
do not give way, are you prepared to embark upon a conflict with a
majority of 350 in the House of Commons, of whom nearly 150 belong to
the party to which most of your Lordships also belong?"
Lord Curzon concluded by saying that he could not vote either way
upon the amendment before the House, because he could not take upon
himself the responsibility of "precipitating a conflict from which your
Lordships would not emerge with credit."
The effect of this speech was intensely dramatic. The antisuffragists
were white with rage; the suffragists were flushed by the certainty of
victory. To Lord Aberconway, who was standing at the bar quite near
me, I said, "What will our majority be?" He replied, "Quite thirty."
The division which followed showed that it was rather more than double
this number, for the figures were: For the clause, 134; against it, 71.
Both Archbishops and the other twelve Bishops present voted for the
clause. Only twelve antisuffrage peers followed Lord Curzon's example
and abstained from voting. If Lord Curzon and his twelve followers
had voted against the clause, it would still have been carried by a
substantial majority.
The Royal Assent was given to the Bill on February 6th, 1918.