Platonism in English poetry of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries
Plato · en
Platonism, then, came as a direct appeal to the religious mind of the
sixteenth and seventeenth centuries which was so constituted that the
element of philosophic revery was blended most naturally with a strain
of pure devotional love. Although the ultimate postulates of that
philosophy were intellectual principles, they were such as could be
grasped by the soul only in its deep passion of love for spiritual
beauty. The condemnation which Baxter passes upon other philosophies
could not be brought with truth against Platonism. “In short,” he says,
“I am an enemy of their philosophy that vilify sense.... The Scripture
that saith of God that He is life and light, saith also that He is love,
and love is complacence, and complacence is joy; and to say God is
infinite, essential love and joy is a better notion than with Cartesians
and Cocceians to say that God and angels and spirits are but a thought
or an idea. What is Heaven to us if there be no love and joy?”[8] This
desire of life and love, along its upper levels of thought, was
satisfied by Platonism; it enabled the poets to forecast the life of the
soul in heaven, and of its anticipation on earth as a love of beauty.
There was a strong tendency, however, throughout this period of
religious poetry, toward a phase of devotional love which may be called
erotic mysticism, or that love for Christ which is characterized less by
admiration and more by tenderness and mere delight in the pure sensuous
experience of love. Contemplation of Christ’s divine nature as essential
beauty is totally absent from this passion. Christ as the object of this
love is conceived only as the perfection of physical beauty; and the
response within the soul of the lover is that of mere sensuous delight
either in the sight of his personal beauties or in the realization of
the union with him. This strain of religious devotion is heard in
Herbert, in Vaughan, and Crashaw. In Herbert, who confessed that he
entered the service of the church in order to be like Christ, “by making
humility lovely,”—a confession which breathes pure emotion,—there was
joined so sensuous a strain that “he seems to rejoice in the thoughts of
that word Jesus, and say, that the adding these words, my Master, to it,
and often repetition of them, seemed to perfume his mind, and leave an
oriental fragrancy in his very breath.”[9] The spectacle of the
crucified Saviour of man was especially influential in keeping this
strain of mystical devotion alive; and the minds of these poets are
continually dwelling upon the beauty of his mangled hands and feet. In a
nature so eminently intellectual as John Donne’s, this strain of feeling
is still present, and in his explanation of the grounds for such a love
is found an excellent account of its varying phases. In one of his
sermons he says: