John Shaqi

Salat-e-Wusta ka Ikhtilaf: Jab Ek Zaati Mushaf ne Kitab se Ek Lafz Ziyada Kaha

Quran 2:238 mein "beech wali namaz" ka zikr hai magar naam nahi. Riwayaat ke mutabiq Hafsa aur Aisha ke zaati mushafon mein chaar lafz ziyada thay - "aur Asr ki namaz". Kya yeh Quran tha, mansookh qiraat, ya likhi hui tafsir? Kitabein, dono column.

By John Shaqi · July 21, 2026 · 15 min read

Jab Ek Zaati Quran ne Kitab se Ek Lafz Ziyada Kaha

Is se pehle ke Quran ka koi sarkari nuskha Islam ke baray shehron ki taraf bheja jata, Nabi Muhammad (SAW) ke chand qareeb tareen sahaba ke paas apne haath se likhe zaati mushaf mojood thay. In mein se do un do khawateen ke thay jo aap (SAW) ke ghar ke ain markaz mein theen: Hafsa bint Umar (RA) aur Aisha bint Abi Bakr (RA), dono aap (SAW) ki azwaaj. Classical riwayaat ke mutabiq, namaz se mutalliq ek mashhoor aayat par in dono ke mushafon mein chaar aise alfaaz ziyada thay jo aaj parhe jane wale Quran mein nahi.

Aayat mukhtasar hai. Izafa us se bhi mukhtasar. Magar sawal purana aur bhaari hai: kya woh alfaaz nazil-shuda Quran thay jo baad mein hata diye gaye, ek aisi qiraat jise Allah ne mansookh kar diya, ya ek insani tashreeh - tafsir ki ek satar - jo baraah-e-raast muqaddas safhe par likh di gayi? Chaudah sadiyon se ulama ne is ka jawab ek se ziyada aawazon mein diya hai. Aaiye kitabein kholte hain.

Continue Reading

Continue reading this article

Sign in free to read in full. Become a member to join the discussion without limits.

Sign in free to read →
Reader$0/mo
  • Read every article
  • Comment and reply (up to 100 words, 10/month)
  • Browse the community
  • Reader badge
Join as Reader
Scholar$8/mo
  • Everything in Writer
  • Scholar badge
  • Featured in the community
Join as Scholar