"95% perfect" : $b The older residences at Nantucket — John Shaqi
"95% perfect" : $b The older residences at NantucketCrosby, Everett Uberto
History
"95% perfect" : $b The older residences at Nantucket
Crosby, Everett Uberto
Historic buildings -- Massachusetts -- Nantucket
This shows what was once a perfect Nantucket house but successive
owners have altered it till nothing of the original remains in view
except two windows. Somebody raised the house and used artificial
stone cement blocks in the foundations as well as in the battlemented
steps to the piazza which has giant columns resting on miniature
anti-rot pipe supports holding up a large flat roof which but partly
conceals a huge exterior cobblestone chimney.
Cement steps and galvanized iron pipe hand rails lead up to the
golden oak front door containing a large beveled plate glass, all
surmounted by a hood held up by supporting brackets of jig-saw design.
A belt of fancy scalloped and diamond-shaped shingles extends across
the front wall and large sheets of glass replace the small window
panes. There is a large bay window.
At the far side a “sun parlor” transforms that end of the structure
and a wide shed roof dormer completely changes the main roof.
We do not intend to comment adversely on these changes in respect
to their individual merits, our purpose being to point out that one
cannot make them and retain an old house.
[Illustration: SECTION OF TOWN DESTROYED BY FIRE 1846
NO. 17]
ALTERATIONS
We have a precious inheritance in this large group of old houses.
Every effort should be made to keep from harming them when making
changes, and to keep from building dissimilar types of new houses in
the old built-up sections. There is ample room outside of the old
districts or elsewhere on the Island for those who determine to build
a place of modern appearance. Yet one can ride a hobby too hard. The
complete purist is often impracticable. One living in an old house
wants to be comfortable and to have adequate space. There is hardly
an old house in town which has not on its visible exterior--at least
somewhere on its four sides--the marks of modernizing as made by
succeeding generations. Fortunately the fronts as a rule have been
but little marred.
Nantucket can be kept “95% perfect” only by not adding to the visible
detractions on its old houses, and by not building new types amidst
the old. Thus this priceless inheritance will be preserved--and
incidentally the values increased--as such houses become less and
less procurable here and elsewhere. We even venture to hope some of
the present detractions will be removed as time goes on.
So far as more room and modern comforts are concerned, an architect
or builder knowing his old Nantucket can usually plan to provide them
in “doing over” an old house and still not harm its exterior. But all
hope is lost if the roof lines are spoiled by large shed-roof dormers
or a dormer room, and only less disfiguring are large “sun parlors,”
piazzas, exterior chimneys, or flat roofed ells or projections, built
where visible from the front.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account