A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
In the fourth figure it may be proved (1) that if the major is
affirmative, the minor must be universal in order to distribute the
middle term; (2) that if the minor is affirmative, the conclusion must
be particular in order to avoid committing the fallacy of illicit minor;
(3) that if either premise is negative, the major must be universal to
avoid the fallacy of illicit major.
(5) A knowledge of the special canons is helpful in that it may be used
to check fallacious reasoning.
(6) Certain mnemonic lines were used by the Schoolmen as an aid in
recalling the nineteen valid moods, and also as a suggestive device to
aid in the process known as Reduction.
The process of reduction is merely a matter of changing to the first
figure the moods of the other figures. This process is no longer
thought to be necessary.
(7) The first figure, called the perfect figure, is the one used
most by scientists, as it is the only figure which proves a universal
affirmative truth. The second figure is the negative, or figure of
disproof, and is used mainly for the purpose of eliminating all the
conditions of the inquiry save _one_. The third figure serves a purpose
in affording an easy way to contradict a universal assertion; this is
the figure of particulars. The fourth figure, because it so closely
resembles the first, is of little value.
=10. ILLUSTRATIVE EXERCISES.=
Question 1a. By making use of the rules for negatives and particulars,
O A A
test the validity of the following moods: I I A
A A I
Answer: The first mood has the negative O as its major premise, and
the affirmative A as its conclusion; the mood is thus invalid; because
a negative premise necessitates a negative conclusion according to
rule 6.
The second mood contains the particular proposition I as its minor
premise, and thus should have a particular conclusion according to
rule 8. But the conclusion A is universal and, therefore, the mood is
invalid.
The premises of the third mood are universal and the conclusion
particular. The mood, however, is valid, because rule 8 does not work
both ways, as does rule 6. When a universal can just as well be drawn,
then the particular becomes a weakened conclusion.
(1b) Using the rules for negatives and particulars, test the validity
A E E
of the following: A O A
E O O
(2a) Paying no regard to “figure,” derive as many conclusions as
possible from the following sets of premises: E A
I E
Answer: _E_. The major premise of this mood, being negative,
_I_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account