A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
(2) Show that Mill’s methods may properly be termed “Inductive
Methods of Scientific Investigation.”
(3) How may it be shown by “agreement” that the high cost of living
is due to the tendency to spend more than we earn?
(4) Assume that you are a member of the Board of Health, and that you
desire to ascertain the cause of the diphtheria epidemic by means
of the principle of agreement.
(5) What is the error involved in coming to the conclusion that to
sit at table where there are thirteen, may mean the death of
_one_ of the thirteen before the end of the year.
(6) Indicate how it could be shown, by the method of difference, that
the mosquito is responsible for the propagation of yellow fever.
(7) “Another experiment similar to this was tried by Plateau, who put
some food of which cockroaches are fond on a table and surrounded
it with a low circular wall of cardboard. He then put some
cockroaches on the table; they evidently scented the food, and
made straight for it. He then removed their antennae.” (Hibben).
Complete and give with explanations the method used.
(8) “In some cases it is impossible to remove an element which is
supposed to be the cause of an effect under investigation.”
Explain and illustrate.
(9) “Extreme care must be taken that, in the withdrawing of any
element, no other element is inadvertently introduced.” Tyndale
supposed he had proved _spontaneous generation_, when, after
sealing in a jar of boiled water a wisp of baked hay, he found,
after many days, indications of life within the bottle. In
transferring the hay to the bottle, he carried the former across
the room. What element was inadvertently introduced?
(10) “The attempt to determine the numerical relations according to
which two phenomena vary, requires the utmost caution as soon as
our inference outsteps the limits of our observations.” (Fowler).
Explain this in connection with the law of concomitant variations.
(11) “When the effects of all known causes are estimated with
exactness and subducted, the _residual facts_ are constantly
appearing in the form of phenomena altogether new, and leading
to the most important conclusions.” Make clear by illustration
this quotation which has reference to the principle of residues.
(12) Explain “invariable conjunction of phenomena.”
(13) Investigate by means of one of the five methods the following
problems:
(1) “All vegetables which grow to root should be planted during
the last two days of the waxing moon.”
(2) “In this section the _south_ wind is the _storm_ wind.”
(3) “Mischief is the outcome of misdirected energy.”
(4) “Bad boys usually receive unjust treatment.”
(5) “An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.”
CHAPTER 19.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account