A History of Greek Economic ThoughtTrever, Albert Augustus
History
A History of Greek Economic Thought
Trever, Albert Augustus
Economics -- Greece -- History; Thesis (Ph. D.)
_Rep._ 552A, C, 564E; cf. _Laws_ 901A, where he refers to the passage
in Hesiod’s _Erga_ 304: κηφηνέσσι κοθούροις. Cf. p. 27, n. 1, above.
Poehlmann (_op. cit._, II, 87 f.) points to Plato’s demand that woman
be freed, so that the total number of free workers may be increased,
but Plato is thinking only of the ruling class.
Footnote 150:
_Laws_ 918B-919C, referring to retail trade; but if he could admit it
for this, he surely could for the industries. Cf. Aristotle’s passage
on liberal and illiberal work (_Pol._ 1337_b_5-22).
Footnote 151:
_Mun. Pul._, V, 105 and note (Vol. XVII, 234 f.), where he refers to
Plato’s diminutive, ἄνθρωπίσκοι, as applied to laborers (_Rep._ 495C;
_Laws_ 741E); _Time and Tide_, 103 (Vol. XVII, 402), 127 (p. 423 and
note); _Crown of Wild Olive_, 2 (Vol. XVIII, 388), on the furnace;
_Lectures on Art_, IV, 123 (Vol. XX, 113); on the evil effects of arts
needing fire, as iron-working, where Xen. _Econ._ iv. 2, 3 is cited.
He makes frequent reference to the Greek attitude, e.g., Vol. XVIII,
241, 461, and above. But he was not absolutely opposed to machinery;
cf. _Cestus Aglaia_, 33 for what is called the finest eulogy of a
machine in English literature. He even anticipated the great future
mechanical development (_Mun. Pul._, 17).
Footnote 152:
_Stones of Venice_ (Vol. X, 201); cf. also IV, 6 (Vol. XI, 202 f.),
where he cites Plato _Alc._ I. 129.
Footnote 153:
_Fors. Clav._, VII, 9 (Vol. XIX, 230).
Footnote 154:
Cf. Vol. XXVII, Intro., p. lxv.
Footnote 155:
_Rep._ 370A-C and many other passages. Cf. _infra_; _Laws_ 846E-847A.
Cf. _infra_ on the unfair interpretation of _Rep._ 421A by Zeller and
others. Plato implies by the passage merely that specialization is
more important for the statesman than for the cobbler (421C).
Footnote 156:
_Rep._ 369C. Adam Smith makes this the basal fact of exchange (_Wealth
of Nations_, I, ii).
Footnote 157:
_Rep._ 370C: πλείω τε ἕκαστα γίγνεται καὶ κάλλιον καὶ ρᾷον, ὅταν ἑἶς
ἓν κατὰ φύσιν, καὶ ἐν καιρῷ σχολὴν τῶν ἄλλων ἄγων, πράττῃ. He first
states the principle less plausibly as a literary device, _Rep._ 369C;
cf. 433A.
Footnote 158:
_Rep._ 370C, B.
Footnote 159:
_Op. cit._, I, chap. ii.
Footnote 160:
So Herbert Spencer, _Principles of Sociology_ (1900), III, 342-49. Cf.
also Ruskin, _Fors Clav._, IV, 15 (Vol. XXVIII, 160).
Footnote 161:
_Rep._ 370B-C, 374B-E.
Footnote 162:
_Op. cit._, I, chap. 1. Plato implies the increase in wealth. Haney
(_op. cit._, p. 41) observes that Plato thought especially of the
advantages of division of labor to the state, rather than to the
individual. Cf. further _Wealth of Nations_, II, Intro.
Footnote 163:
_Rep._ 370C-371B; cf. DuBois, _op. cit._, p. 37.
Footnote 164:
_Rep._ 370C-D.
Footnote 165:
371C.
Footnote 166:
371B; _Laws_ 918B.
Footnote 167:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account