A modern symposiumDickinson, G. Lowes (Goldsworthy Lowes)
Philosophy
A modern symposium
Dickinson, G. Lowes (Goldsworthy Lowes)
Great Britain -- Social conditions; Social problems
"And as property is merely a means, so is government. To us of the new
generation nothing is more surprising and more repugnant, than the
importance attached by politicians to formulae which have long since
lost whatever significance they may once have possessed. Democracy,
representation, trust in the people and the rest, all this to us is the
idlest verbiage. It is notorious, even to those who make most play
with these phrases, that the people do not govern themselves, that they
cannot do so, and that they would make a great mess of it if they
could. The truth is, that we are living politically on a tradition
which arose when by government was meant government by a class, when
one man or a few exploited the rest in the name of the state, and when
therefore it was of imperative importance to bring to bear upon those
who were in power the brute and unintelligent weight of the mass. The
whole democratic movement, though it assumed a positive intellectual
form, was in fact negative in its aim and scope. It meant simply, we
will not be exploited. But that end has now been attained. There is
no fear now that government will be oppressive; and the only problem of
the future is, how to make it efficient. But efficiency, it is
certain, can never be secured by democratic machinery. We must, as
Allison rightly maintains, have trained and skilled persons. How these
are to be secured is a matter of detail, though no doubt of important
detail; and it is one that the new generation will have to solve. What
they will want, in any case, is government. MacCarthy's idea of
anarchy is--well, if he will pardon my saying so, it is hardly worthy
of his intelligence. You cannot regulate society, any more than you
can spin cotton, by the light of nature and a good heart. MacCarthy
mistakes the character of government altogether, when he imagines its
essence to be compulsion. Its essence is direction; and direction,
whatever the form of society, is, or should be, reserved for the wise.
It is for wise direction that the coming generations cry; and it is our
business to see that they get it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account