"The figures show, then, that hookworm disease unmistakably affects
mental development. Treatment alleviates this condition to some extent
but it does not, immediately, at least, permit the child to gain as he
would if he had not had the disease. And the figures apparently further
show that prolonged infection may produce prolonged effects upon
mentality,--effects from which the individual may never recover."
CHAPTER II.
METHOD AND PROCEDURE
The following investigation was carried on during the year and a half
from October, 1919, to April, 1921. The subjects were pupils at Public
School 64, Manhattan, or patients at the Manhattan Eye, Ear and Throat
Hospital. All were boys, between the ages of six and fourteen years. The
testing in the study of improvement was done by the investigator,
assisted by three other examiners, all competent and experienced in the
technique of giving psychological tests.
A Statistical Study
In addition to the more lengthy experiment, a statistical study was
made, comparing the intelligence levels of two groups of children, the
one selected for the presence of tonsils, the other for freedom from
them. These two groups were obtained from a large group of 530 children
whose I.Q.'s were gained from the records of Public School 64, where, so
far as possible, all children are tested upon entering school. We had,
therefore, a group unselected for intelligence level.
All the children for whom we had I.Q.'s were examined by the school
nurse or physician. On the basis of this examination the two groups were
selected. The tonsil group consisted of those cases which in the opinion
of the nurse or doctor, were pronounced enough to deserve treatment. The
normal group was composed of those who were not defective, or in whom
the defect was so slight as not to demand treatment. The two groups were
arranged each in a surface of distribution according to the I.Q.'s of
the members. The results of the distribution appear in Table I, and in
Figs. I. and II.
A Study of Improvement After Treatment
The method employed here is based on the hypothesis that if a physical
defect is the cause of retardation in mental or physical development,
removal of the cause will tend to lessen the retardation. In other
words, if a child's working efficiency is lowered by the effects of
adenoids and bad tonsils, their removal should, unless such lowering be
permanent, be followed after a reasonable time by an improvement. But
improvement in efficiency, following the removal of adenoids and tonsils
proves nothing unless we shall compare it with the change in efficiency
of a control group, whose members have not been operated on, and who
thus still suffer from the effects of the growths.
Selection of Cases
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account