The selection of the children for the experiment was effected in the
following manner. The teachers at Public School 64 were asked to report
any cases which had come to their notice, as being seriously afflicted
with adenoids and diseased tonsils. In this way a fairly large group was
obtained. The parents of the children were visited with the purpose of
obtaining permission for examination and operation at the Post Graduate
Hospital. It was fairly easy to obtain permission to have the children
examined. They were taken in groups of four or five to the clinic, the
experimenter attending in person every examination in order to learn
from the doctors the degree of the defect. As a result of this method,
we discarded all those cases where there was any doubt as to the serious
nature of the defect.
From the large group examined, we were finally successful in securing
operative treatment for 10 children. Discarding the cases where defect
was slight, there remained a number of children who, for one reason or
another, did not undergo operation. In some instances the parents
refused their permission, in some they failed to keep appointments, in
one or two there was sickness in the family, and in a number the
hospital was overcrowded and could not receive the children. All members
of this group were examined,--to the number of fifty-six, and from them
the control group was finally selected.
Since we were unable to secure a large test group from Public School 64,
the experiment was continued at the Manhattan Eye, Ear and Throat
Hospital where opportunity was given for testing the children after they
had been admitted for operation. In order to be sure that in each case
the defect was sufficiently pronounced to render decisive the results of
the experiment, each child's card was examined. Only those children
were included who were undergoing operation for both adenoids and
tonsils.
It may be here remarked that mental tests were given to these children
on the morning of operation, and in some cases only a short time before
it. The possibility suggests itself, therefore, that the results of the
tests may have been influenced by excitement or fright on the part of
the patients. Actually, however, this did not seem to be the case. The
children were perfectly cheerful and showed no signs of nervousness. The
tests were given in a waiting room with the door closed so that any
disturbing sights and sounds were eliminated. The possible lowering of
the performance by the causes mentioned would tend to exaggerate the
improvement shown by the retests, so that in the light of the results,
it will be seen that they could have had little effect.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account