Albyn; or, Scotland and the futureMacDiarmid, Hugh
History
Albyn; or, Scotland and the future
MacDiarmid, Hugh
Scotland
seeks to perfect, and even to intensify, different cultures already
existent among different peoples, and sets for its ideal that each
people has, first, the right to its own interpretation of life;
and, second, the duty of understanding, and sympathizing with,
the different interpretations given by its neighbours as fully as
possible. Back of this type of international education lies the
belief that differentiation in matters of culture is more valuable
to life than a stereotyped homogeneity. This, so far as Scotland
is concerned, is the aim and object of the Scottish Renaissance
movement; and it is high time that the Scottish Educational System
was attempting to change-over to this type of education rather than
adhering partly to the imperialistic and partly to the eclectic
types, both of which, as Professor Zimmern says, “belong rather to
the past than to the present,” except, alas, in Scotland, which
once prided itself on leading the world in matters of education. A
recent Committee of Enquiry, set up by the Glasgow branch of the
Educational Institute of Scotland, reports that no school-book
dealing with Scottish history is of a satisfactory character. This,
although a remarkable advance in professional admission, is a
sheer understatement. Scottish history is only now in the process
of being rediscovered and, once the labours of the new school of
Scottish historical researchers come to be synthetized, it will be
found that even such comparatively “Scottish” Scottish Histories
as Hume Brown’s have to be thrown overboard, as little more than
a mass of English propaganda. It is only within recent years that
any attempt has been made to teach even such “Scottish history”
in Scottish schools, and then subsidiarily to English, and, as it
were, as a make-weight or after-thought—to the older children. Scots
literature is in even worse case, although here, too, there has
been a slight improvement during the past decade. The increasing—if
still insignificant—Scoticization of Scottish Education during
recent years is, of course, not a product of the propaganda of the
Scottish Renaissance Group. To what is it attributable? How can it be
accounted for if the policy of England and, even more determinedly,
of Anglo-Scotland, let alone the over-riding tendency of modern
industrialism, is towards the complete assimilation of Scotland
to England? In my opinion it is a product partly of the latent
criticism of the industrial order and partly of a realization of the
cultural exhaustion of English (_vide_ “_Pomona_”)—an instinctive
protective re-assembling of the forces suppressed by the existing
order of things which has made for the predominancy of English.
This explanation accords with the doctrine Spengler expounds in his
_Downfall of the Western World_. “The Caledonian Antisyzygy,” instead
of being a disparate thing destined to play a baroque, ornamental,
or disfiguring rôle—_chacun à son goût_—in English literature may be
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account