American painting and its tradition : $b as represented by Inness, Wyant, Martin, Homer, La Farge, Whistler, Chase, Alexander, SargentVan Dyke, John C.
History
American painting and its tradition : $b as represented by Inness, Wyant, Martin, Homer, La Farge, Whistler, Chase, Alexander, Sargent
Van Dyke, John C.
Painters -- United States; Painting -- United States
It would seem then that however much pride we may take in Sargent’s
achievements we can hardly be proud because he is peculiarly our own.
He is not American in the sense of knowing the land and the people and
reflecting our life and civilization. Just as little has his birth in
Italy made him Italian or his residence in France and England made him
French or English. No country can claim him, no people can appropriate
him, for in reality he is a citizen of the world at large--the
manner of man we sometimes call a cosmopolite. If there is one place
above another that he can be traced to and said to emanate from it
is Paris; and Paris is no longer merely the first city of France.
It, too, has become cosmopolitan--the centre of modern life and the
gathering-place of the world’s knowledge, intelligence, and fashion.
Sargent reflects its taste and its skill, but not anything else that
is peculiarly French, not anything that smacks of the French soil. The
accomplishments of Paris are his, but without the sentiment or the
feeling that is French.
It is questionable if a man who is equally at home in London, Paris,
Florence, and New York will or can have a very strong sentiment about
any one of those places. He can hardly spend a winter in the United
States and become vitally interested in democracy, and the next winter
go to England and fall deeply in love with aristocracy. Nor can he
live for a few months in Spain or Germany and penetrate to the quick
the life and character of its people. The cosmopolite who moves hither
and yon about the globe hardly ever takes to heart the affairs and
interests of those with whom he is temporarily sojourning. On the
contrary, it is rather his attitude of mind that nothing is to be taken
too seriously. To ruffle one’s composure with an emotion or to worry
one’s self about a sentiment is the very thing he seeks to avoid.
He accepts the facts as facts, concerns himself with the appearance
of things, is a stickler for the refinements, and a great student
of manners, methods, and styles. He quickly absorbs whatsoever is
artistic or intelligent or learned, his perceptions are very acute, his
knowledge and manner are polished to the last degree; but the strong
feeling that, after all, lies at the bottom of great endeavor finds no
utterance in his work, and the national beliefs that are really the
insistent and persistent things in both literature and art are not the
mainspring of his action.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account