American War Ballads and Lyrics, Volume 1 (of 2): A Collection of the Songs and Ballads of the Colonial Wars, the Revolutions, the War of 1812-15, the War with Mexico and the Civil War
History
American War Ballads and Lyrics, Volume 1 (of 2): A Collection of the Songs and Ballads of the Colonial Wars, the Revolutions, the War of 1812-15, the War with Mexico and the Civil War
United States -- History -- Poetry; War poetry, American; War songs -- United States -- Texts
The song concerning the "Constitution and Guerrière," for example, is
very nearly as destitute of poetic quality as metrical writing can be,
and yet no editor of a collection like this would think of omitting a
piece that had for so many years stirred the hearts of patriots and
moved them to rejoice in the achievements of their country's heroes.
The complex nature of the considerations that must determine the choice
of poems for inclusion is but one of several difficulties encountered
in the execution of such a task as this. In any event, many things must
be omitted which merit insertion, and the reader who misses a favorite
piece is prompt to point to others which seem to him less worthy,
and to ask why these were not made to give place to the one omitted.
There are three answers to be made to the challenge of such a reader:
first, that his judgment in the matter may be wrong; second, that the
editor, being human, may have erred in his choice; and third, that in a
collection intended to be broadly representative rather than complete,
preference must sometimes be given to the less worthy piece which
happens to reflect some phase of sentiment not otherwise presented,
even at the cost of sacrificing the worthier one which illustrates
aspects otherwise sufficiently shown.
So much by way of explanation, not of apology; for if a book be in need
of apology, no apology can be sufficient for it.
In the matter of arrangement the poems naturally fall into five
principal groups. Within the groups the chronology of the events
referred to has been adopted as a general rule of arrangement, while
for the most part poems that have no reference to particular events
or epochs have been placed at the end of the groups to which they
belong. No rule of arrangement, however, has been permitted to dominate
other considerations where other considerations have seemed the more
important.
In presenting the ballads and lyrics of the civil war, it has been
thought best not to give those from the North and those from the
South in separate groups. There are several objections to such an
arrangement, of which it is perhaps sufficient to mention a single one,
namely, that by the separation of poems relating to the same events or
the same aspects of the struggle, much of their historical significance
is lost, and the comparison which the reflective reader naturally
wishes to make between the moods, impulses, aspirations, and points of
view of the poets on opposite sides is rendered much more difficult and
less satisfactory.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account