In learning and reducing to writing an unwritten language there are
always several elements that increase and complicate the difficulties.
There is what is in your own mind as the object for which you are
seeking a word, and there is what the native thinks is the object for
which you are wanting the word, which two things may be very different;
again, when you are searching for a word to embody an abstract quality
there is, on the one hand, the meaning you attach to the words you use
as illustrative of the idea for which you want the word; and there is,
on the other hand, the meaning which your native lad attaches to the
words you employ, and the two sets of meanings may widely vary. You may
unknowingly employ a wrong phrase in your description of the quality you
are wanting a word to express, and your teacher is either puzzled or
thrown entirely off the scent, and the result leads to a disastrous
mistake and, unless corrected later, to a false, misleading translation.
Suppose you want a word for healthiness; you say that a man walks well
every day, paddles for long distances without fatigue, eats his food
heartily, has no pains in his body, and never needs to go to a
medicine-man. “What do you call that?” Your helper will consider for a
moment, and then reply: “_Abe na bonganga._”
By and by you go over the description with another person, and he says
of such a man: “_Abe na nkonjo._” A few days later, in order to check
the former teachers, you try another young man, and he tells you: “_Abe
na nkasu._”
In due time, however, you discover that _abe na bonganga_ means: he has
a powerful charm; that _abe na nkonjo_ = he has good luck; and _abe na
nkasu_ = he is very strong; and that _nkuli_ is the proper word for
healthiness.
Your helpers have not purposely led you astray, for they have simply
stated from their point of view how they would regard such a fortunate
man who can walk, paddle, eat well, has no pains in his body, and never
needs medicine—he must possess a powerful charm, or have wonderful luck,
or be exceedingly strong. When you know the natives better you find they
rarely talk about their health, hence _abe na nkuli_ = he has
healthiness, would not come readily to their minds.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account