An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
3. We must take the constitution of the human mind as we find it, and
not as we may judge it ought to be;—thus I am led on to another remark,
which is at first sight disadvantageous to Certitude. Introspection of
our intellectual operations is not the best of means for preserving us
from intellectual hesitations. To meddle with the springs of thought
and action is really to weaken them; and, as to that argumentation
which is the preliminary to Certitude, it may indeed be unavoidable,
but, as in the case of other serviceable allies, it is not so easy
to discard it, after it has done its work, as it was in the first
instance to obtain its assistance. Questioning, when encouraged on
any subject-matter, readily becomes a habit, and leads the mind to
substitute exercises of inference for assent, whether simple or
complex. Reasons for assenting suggest reasons for not assenting,
and what were realities to our imagination, while our assent was
simple, may become little more than notions, when we have attained
to certitude. Objections and difficulties tell upon the mind; it
may lose its elasticity, and be unable to throw them off. And thus,
even as regards things which it may be absurd to doubt, we may, in
consequence of some past suggestion of the possibility of error, or
of some chance association to their disadvantage, be teazed from
time to time and hampered by involuntary questionings, as if we were
not certain, when we are. Nay, there are those, who are visited with
these even permanently, as a sort of _muscæ volitantes_ of their
mental vision, ever flitting to and fro, and dimming its clearness
and completeness—visitants, for which they are not responsible, and
which they know to be unreal, still so seriously interfering with
their comfort and even with their energy, that they may be tempted to
complain that even blind prejudice has more of quiet and of durability
than certitude.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account