An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
And quite as difficult is it to create or to apprehend by description
images of mental facts, of which we have no direct experience. I may
indeed, as I have already said, bring home to my mind so complex a fact
as an historical character, by composition out of my experiences about
character generally; Tiberius, James the First, Louis the Eleventh, or
Napoleon; but who is able to infuse into me, or how shall I imbibe, a
sense of the peculiarities of the style of Cicero or Virgil, if I have
not read their writings? or how shall I gain a shadow of a perception
of the wit or the grace ascribed to the conversation of the French
salons, being myself an untravelled John Bull? And so again, as regards
the affections and passions of our nature, they are _sui generis_
respectively, and incommensurable, and must be severally experienced
in order to be apprehended really. I can understand the _rabbia_ of
a native of Southern Europe, if I am of a passionate temper myself;
and the taste for speculation or betting found in great traders or
on the turf, if I am fond of enterprise or games of chance; but on
the other hand, not all the possible descriptions of headlong love
will make me comprehend the _delirium_, if I have never had a fit of
it; nor will ever so many sermons about the inward satisfaction of
strict conscientiousness create in my mind the image of a virtuous
action and its attendant sentiments, if I have been brought up to
lie, thieve and indulge my appetites. Thus we meet with men of the
world who cannot enter into the very idea of devotion, and think,
for instance, that, from the nature of the case, a life of religious
seclusion must be either one of unutterable dreariness or abandoned
sensuality, because they know of no exercise of the affections but what
is merely human; and with others again, who, living in the home of
their own selfishness, ridicule as something fanatical and pitiable the
self-sacrifices of generous high-mindedness and chivalrous honour. They
cannot create images of these things, any more than children can on the
contrary of vice, when they ask whereabouts and who the bad men are;
for they have no personal memories, and have to content themselves with
notions drawn from books or from what others tell them.
So much on the apprehension of things and on the real sense in our use
of language; now let us pass on to the notional sense.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account