An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
So far the indiscriminate reading of Scripture has been of service;
still, much more is necessary than the benefits which I have
enumerated, to answer to the idea of a Religion; whereas our national
form professes to be little more than thus reading the Bible and
living a correct life. It is not a religion of persons and things, of
acts of faith and of direct devotion; but of sacred scenes and pious
sentiments. It has been comparatively careless of creed and catechism;
and has in consequence shown little sense of the need of consistency
in the matter of its teaching. Its doctrines are not so much facts, as
stereotyped aspects of facts; and it is afraid, so to say, of walking
round them. It induces its followers to be content with this meagre
view of revealed truth; or, rather, it is suspicious and protests,
or is frightened, as if it saw a figure in a picture move out of its
frame, when our Lord, the Blessed Virgin, or the Holy Apostles, are
spoken of as real beings, and really such as Scripture implies them to
be. I am not denying that the assent which it inculcates and elicits is
genuine as regards its contracted range of doctrine, but it is at best
notional. What Scripture especially illustrates from its first page to
its last, is God’s Providence; and that is nearly the only doctrine
held with a real assent by the mass of religious Englishmen. Hence the
Bible is so great a solace and refuge to them in trouble. I repeat, I
am not speaking of particular schools and parties in England, whether
of the High Church or the Low, but of the mass of piously-minded and
well-living people in all ranks of the community.
3. _Opinion._
That class of assents which I have called Credence, being a spontaneous
acceptance of the various informations, which are by whatever means
conveyed to our minds, sometimes goes by the name of Opinion. When
we speak of a man’s opinions, what do we mean, but the collection
of notions which he happens to have, and does not easily part with,
though he has neither sufficient proof nor firm grasp of them? This
is true; however, Opinion is a word of various significations, and
I prefer to use it in my own. Besides standing for Credence, it is
sometimes taken to mean Conviction, as when we speak of the “variety of
religious opinions,” or of being “persecuted for religious opinions,”
or of our having “no opinion on a particular point,” or of another
having “no religious opinions.” And sometimes it is used in contrast
with Conviction, as synonymous with a light and casual, though genuine
assent; thus, if a man was every day changing his mind, that is, his
assents, we might say, that he was very changeable in his opinions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account