An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
It does not meet the case to refer to the law of averages, for such
laws deal with percentages, not with individuals, and it is about
individuals that I am speaking. That this particular man out of
the three millions congregated in the metropolis, was to have the
experience of this catastrophe, and to be the select victim to appease
that law of averages, no statistical tables could foretell, even
though they could determine that it was in the fates that in that week
or day some four persons in the length and breadth of London should
be run over. And in like manner that this or that person should have
the particular experiences necessary for real assent on any point,
that the Deist should become a Theist, the Erastian a Catholic, the
Protectionist a Free-trader, the Conservative a Legitimist, the high
Tory an out-and-out Democrat, are facts, each of which may be the
result of a multitude of coincidences in one and the same individual,
coincidences which we have no means of determining, and which,
therefore, we may call accidents. For—
“There’s a Divinity that shapes our ends,
Rough hew them how we will.”
Such accidents are the characteristics of persons, as _differentiæ_ and
properties are the characteristics of species or natures.
That a man dies when deprived of air, is not an accident of his person,
but a law of his nature; that he cannot live without quinine or opium,
or out of the climate of Madeira, is his own peculiarity. If all men
every where usually had the yellow fever once in their lives, we should
call it (speaking according to our knowledge) a law of the human
constitution; if the inhabitants of a particular country commonly had
it, we should call it a law of the climate; if a healthy man has a
fever in a healthy place, in a healthy season, we call it an accident,
though it be reducible to the coincidence of laws, because there is
no known law of their coincidence. To be rational, to have speech, to
pass through successive changes of mind and body from infancy to death,
belong to man’s nature; to have a particular history, to be married or
single, to have children or to be childless, to live a given number of
years, to have a certain constitution, moral temperament, intellectual
outfit, mental formation, these and the like, taken all together, are
the accidents which make up our notion of a man’s person, and are the
ground-work or condition of his particular experiences.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account