Anomalies of the English lawChester, S. Beach (Samuel Beach)
History
Anomalies of the English law
Chester, S. Beach (Samuel Beach)
Law; Law -- Great Britain -- History
This simple means of obtaining marital freedom contains much to
recommend itself to the unhappy people who are barbarously tied
together to-day, in spite of their mutual antagonism of temperament and
desire. In France, the Civil Code authorises divorce on the following
grounds: “(1st) Adultery by the wife, or by the husband if he kept a
concubine in the common dwelling-house; (2nd) Outrageous conduct or
ill-usage by either of the spouses; (3rd) Condemnation to an infamous
punishment; and (4th) In a certain limited class of cases by mutual
consent, but only upon the conditions and under the restrictions
specified, which are of the most stringent character.”[5]
It is interesting to refer to the Scottish law on the same subject,
particularly when it is stated by an eminent Scottish judge, Lord
Mackenzie, in his work on Roman Law. “By the law of Scotland a divorce
may be obtained by the husband or the wife on the ground of adultery,
or of wilful desertion for four years together, without just cause,
after adopting the forms of the Act 1573, c. 55, so far as these are
still required.... In suing for a divorce in Scotland the wife has
precisely the same rights as the husband. If she can prove adultery
or wilful desertion for four years by the husband, that entitles her
to take proceedings for a divorce, in the same manner as adultery or
wilful desertion on her part entitles him to a similar remedy....
The action of divorce proceeds before the Court of Session, and the
right to institute it is personal to the husband or the wife. As a
preliminary, the pursuer is required to make oath that the suit is
not collusive. In this and all consistorial actions the summons must
be served upon the defender personally when he is not resident in
Scotland; yet, upon evidence to the satisfaction of the court that the
defender cannot be found, edictal citation will be held sufficient;
but in every case where the citation is edictal the summons must be
served on the children of the marriage, if any, and on one or more
of the next-of-kin of the defender, exclusive of their children,
when the children and next-of-kin are known and resident within the
United Kingdom; and such children and next-of-kin, whether cited or
so resident or not, may appear and state defences to the action....
When the husband sues for divorce on the ground of adultery, he may
cite the alleged adulterer as a co-defender, and the court may order
him to pay the whole or any part of the costs, or may dismiss him from
the action, as may seem just.... In the case of adultery, divorce
is barred by condonation or forgiveness, as well as by collusion or
connivance. Recrimination cannot be pleaded as a defence to exclude the
suit, but it may be stated in a counter-action, as the mutual guilt may
affect the patrimonial interests of the parties.... The legal effect
of divorce on the ground of wilful desertion under the Act 1573, c.
55, is, that the offending husband is bound to restore the tocher
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account