Chosen. 1st Guess. 2nd Guess. BRIGHT RED _Bright Red_ LIGHT GREEN _Light Green_ YELLOW _Dark Blue_ _Yellow_ BRIGHT YELLOW _Bright Yellow_ DARK RED _Blue_ _Dark Red_ DARK BLUE _Orange_ _Dark Blue_ ORANGE _Green_ _Heliotrope_ The percipient himself told the agents to change character of object after each actual failure, thus getting new sensations. Percipient was told to go into next room and get something. _1st Object._ SILVER INKSTAND chosen.--Percipient says, _I think of something, but it is too bright and easy. It is the silver inkstand._ Percipient told to get something in next room. _2nd Object._ A GLASS CANDLESTICK.--Percipient went to right corner of the room and to the cabinet with the object on it, but could not distinguish which object. Percipient had handkerchief off to be able to walk, but was not followed by agents, and did not see them. Agents found percipient standing with hands over candlestick undecided. From the percipient's descriptions it would seem that the impression here was of a visual nature, though Dr. Thaw himself says, "I cannot describe my sensation as a visualisation of any kind. It seemed rather to be by some wholly subjective process that I knew what the agents were looking at." It is not always, however, an easy task to analyse one's own sensations; and, on the whole, it seems more probable that there was visualisation, but of a very faint and ideal kind. No. 5.--By MR. MALCOLM GUTHRIE. Reference has already been made to the long series of experiments carried on during the years 1883-85 by Mr. Malcolm Guthrie of Liverpool. During a great part of the series he was assisted by Mr. James Birchall, Hon. Sec. of the Liverpool Literary and Philosophical Society. Professor Oliver Lodge, Edmund Gurney, Professor Herdman, and others co-operated from time to time. Throughout there were two percipients only, Miss R. and Miss E. The experiments were conducted and the results recorded with great care and thoroughness; and the whole series, in its length, its variety, and its completeness, forms perhaps the most important single contribution to the records of experimental thought-transference in the normal state.[21] Summing up, in July 1885, the results attained, Mr. Guthrie writes:--