Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuriesHitchcock, Henry-Russell
History
Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuries
Hitchcock, Henry-Russell
Architecture, Modern -- 19th century; Architecture, Modern -- 20th century
The only big Paris church of the sixties of much real distinction—the
only French church, for that matter—is Saint-Pierre-de-Montrouge at the
intersection of the Avenue du Maine and the Avenue d’Orléans. This was
built by J.-A.-E. Vaudremer (1829-1914), a pupil of Blouet and Gilbert,
in 1864-70. Romanesque and Early Christian—perhaps more specifically
Syrian—in inspiration,[194] this basilica is notably direct in its
structural expression, nobly scaled, expressively composed, and
restrained almost to the point of crudity in its detailing (Plate 72A).
Vaudremer’s Santé Prison off the Boulevard Arago in Paris, which was
commissioned in 1862 and built in 1865-85, is also Romanesquoid or at
least in a sort of very simple _Rundbogenstil_. The still quite
Durandesque character of this prison illustrates Vaudremer’s close
linkage, through the work of his two masters, who had both specialized
in designing prisons and asylums under Louis Philippe, with the
classicizing rationalism of 1800. His much later Lycées of the eighties,
Buffon and Molière in Paris and those at Grenoble and Montauban, on the
other hand, reflect the more Gothic rationalism of Viollet-le-Duc (see
Chapter 11).
Vaudremer’s work may have had some influence, around 1870, on the
American Richardson, who was still a student in Paris when
Saint-Pierre-de-Montrouge was begun (see Chapter 13). However, no
significant line of development led forward in France from his sort of
church design. In a smaller and later Parisian church, Notre-Dame in the
Rue d’Auteuil of 1876-83, Vaudremer himself showed no further
development of his personal style, though the interior here is not
unimpressive in its scale and proportions.
The vast and prominent church of the Sacré-Cœur on Montmartre in
Paris was begun by Paul Abadie[195] (1812-84), a pupil of Leclerc,
well after the Second Empire was over in 1874, and largely finished
before the end of the century by the younger Magne (Lucien,
1849-1916). This is Romanesque in inspiration, too, but painfully
archaeological—’painfully’, because its architect, in carrying out
the restoration of his principal medieval exemplar, Saint-Front at
Périgueux, seems to have sought to provide ‘precedent’ for several
of the features that he introduced here! Yet the bold exploitation
of the remarkable site of this church, dominating Paris from the
heights of Montmartre, and the bubble-like silhouette of its cluster
of domes when seen from a distance give the Sacré-Cœur positive
qualities lacking in most other French ecclesiastical work of the
later nineteenth century except Saint-Pierre-de-Montrouge.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account