Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuriesHitchcock, Henry-Russell
History
Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuries
Hitchcock, Henry-Russell
Architecture, Modern -- 19th century; Architecture, Modern -- 20th century
Most of the Neo-Gothic in Canada up to this time is more properly to be
considered Early rather than High Victorian (see Chapter 6). An
exception to this, perhaps, is University College in Toronto, designed
in 1856 by F. W. Cumberland (1821-81), who had come out from England in
1847. Yet its rich and rather bombastic Norman design is closer to
English work of the earlier decades of the century than to the
round-arched Ruskinian Gothic of the fifties.
Australia, the other major British Dominion, had nothing comparable to
Canada to offer in this period. Wardell’s English, Scottish, and
Australian Bank in Melbourne is a passable example of secular High
Victorian Gothic but no more than that. St John Evangelist’s, which he
built at Toorak south of Melbourne in 1860-73, is handsomer but very
simple—still almost Puginian, indeed—and all of monochrome ashlar. The
enormous Catholic cathedral of Melbourne, St Patrick’s, which Wardell
began in 1860, is more Continental in character, with two west towers
like Renwick’s St Patrick’s in New York and also a tall crossing tower
completed only in 1939. The Catholic cathedral of Adelaide, St Francis
Xavier’s, begun in 1870 and still without its intended western spires,
reputedly goes back to a design prepared by Pugin before his death in
1852. But even the later design of his son E. W. Pugin, on which the
executed work was actually based, must have been much modified over the
years by W. H. Bagot (b. 1880), H. H. Jory (b. 1880), and Lewis
Laybourne-Smith (b. 1888), who successively supervised the job. It is
certainly no happier an example of High Victorian Gothic than Wardell’s
Catholic cathedral in Melbourne.
The Anglican cathedral in Melbourne, St Paul’s, having been begun in
1850 from designs by Butterfield, ought to be finer. But Butterfield had
made the drawings as early as 1847, before even he was a High Victorian,
and the laggard execution of the church by Joseph Reed evidently
entailed much modification of the original designs. Moreover, the spires
by John Barr date only from 1934. For the very late Anglican cathedral
at Brisbane, St John’s, perhaps the finest of the lot, which was begun
in 1901 by F. L. Pearson from earlier designs by his father J. L.
Pearson as has already been mentioned, Butterfield had also prepared
designs in 1884.
The architecture of the Dominions remained Colonial in spirit, as these
notes on a few Australian churches indicate, well into the present
century. First the able Frank Wills, moreover, the English-born
architect of Montreal Cathedral, and then Fuller & Laver were drawn away
from Canada to the United States, where opportunities were greater.
Despite the great interest of the Government Buildings at Ottawa, it was
in the United States rather than the British Dominions that the High
Victorian Gothic proved a stimulus to such highly original achievement
as Furness’s in the seventies.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account