Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuriesHitchcock, Henry-Russell
History
Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuries
Hitchcock, Henry-Russell
Architecture, Modern -- 19th century; Architecture, Modern -- 20th century
The Place de la Concorde, projected by A.-J. Gabriel (1692-1782) at the
end of the Baroque Age, continued to lack, even after a half century and
more, appropriate monuments to terminate the cross axis. The building of
a big church at the head of the Rue Royale to close the vista between
Gabriel’s two colonnaded ranges on the north side of the square had
bogged down well before the Revolution; across the river the much
earlier Palais Bourbon, set at an angle, was even more awkward than
before, now that the roof of the Salle des Cinq Cents rose above it.
Since the amelioration of this southern terminal required only a tall
masking façade set at right angles to the axis, this was promptly
provided. Poyet in 1806-8 used the most obvious Romantic Classical
solution for such a problem, a high blank wall with a ten-columned
temple portico at its centre. The result is certainly an urbanistic
success, if without any particular intrinsic interest; the raising of
the portico above a high range of steps ensured, for example, its
visibility from the square across the bridge. The form of the pediment
was slightly modified and the sculpture by Cortot added in 1837-41.
In 1761 Pierre Contant d’Ivry (1698-1777) and, after his death, G.-M.
Couture (1732-99) had made successive projects for a church dedicated to
the Magdalen at the head of the Rue Royale, the latter already proposing
that it be surrounded by a Classical peristyle. This structure, which
was as yet barely begun, Napoleon now decided should be not a church but
a Temple de la Gloire—he reversed his decision in 1813 after the Battle
of Leipzig and the loss of Spain. For such a temple he understandably
preferred, in the competition held in 1806, neither the first nor the
second premiated design, both of church-like character, but one by
Pierre Vignon (1763-1828) that proposed the erection of an enormous
Corinthian temple on a high Roman podium. Inside, a series of square
bays covered with domes on pendentives supported by giant Corinthian
columns provided a structural solution technically Byzantine but as
imperially Roman in scale and detailing as the exterior.
Construction of the Madeleine, begun in 1807, dragged on interminably.
J.-J.-M. Huvé (1783-1852) succeeded Vignon as architect in 1828 and,
like the Arc de l’Étoile, the edifice was finally finished only under
Louis Philippe in 1845. The interior has a somewhat funereal solemnity,
more characteristic of the post-Napoleonic regimes than of the period of
its initiation. The rather obvious temple form of the exterior is
redeemed by the superb siting, the really grand scale, and the rich
pedimental sculpture by Lemaire. Like Chalgrin’s arch, Vignon’s
Madeleine has continued to provide a major monumental nexus in the
urbanism of Paris ever since.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account