Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction TypeHoch, August
Science
Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction Type
Hoch, August
Manic-depressive illness; Stupor
Possibly vague sexual allusions are also contained in the
following: She said one day to the doctor, “Everything went
wrong last night, good, pure, true and holy doctor, I led
you astray and you were dying last night, may the Almighty
God forgive me, I ought to have died, but I fought it out,
for, if I had died, my mother’s soul would not have been
saved in Heaven and from the flames of Hell.” Again, “I
will not look at you again, good, pure, holy doctor of the
world.” (Why?) “I am afraid I will lead you astray.” And
also: “I led James. Peter astray too.” It should be added
that she sometimes masturbated rather shamelessly.
She said she heard her mother’s voice. (What did she say?)
“Something in the sky for me, angels call for me.” (What do
the angels say?) “The name of my good mother in Heaven.”
Again she said she had heard her mother the night she came
here. (What did she say?) “It was like a voice--feed the
calf--that means me, I suppose.”
Then after a month the stupor became more continuous. She
lay totally inactive for the most part, had to be fed,
soiled herself, drooled saliva, was at times cataleptic,
often rigid. Her limbs became cyanotic. A few times tears
were seen. On other occasions she whispered “peace,” or
“peace for hazing,” or “pray--peace,” or “I like to be
good.” Usually no responses could be obtained.
After some months she was at times seen laughing. This
gradually passed into a state of total disinterestedness
and inaccessibility. She could finally be made to polish
the floor in an automatic fashion, but never spoke, and
five years after admission she was transferred to another
hospital, where she died (eleven years after admission to
the ward of the Institute) without any change in her mental
condition having taken place.
CASE 24.--_Adele M._ Age: 22. Admitted to the Psychiatric
Institute November 11, 1904.
_P. H._ The father stated that the patient was always
“cranky,” had outbursts of temper, even when a small child
and was quarrelsome; also said that she was “seclusive,”
had few friends, was averse to meeting people, never had a
beau. She was taken out of school at 14 because she was not
promoted on two successive occasions from the same class.
Then she was put to work, but she was usually discharged
for incompetency.
_Onset of Psychosis:_ Three years before admission it was
noted that she laughed occasionally without cause. She was
idle. This laughing, and also crying, was sometimes more
frequent, again less noticeable.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account