That which psycho-analysis reveals in the transference phenomena with
neurotics can also be observed in the life of normal persons. It here
gives the impression of a pursuing fate, a daemonic trait in their
destiny, and psycho-analysis has from the outset regarded such a life
history as in a large measure self-imposed and determined by infantile
influences. The compulsion which thereby finds expression is in no way
different from the repetition-compulsion of neurotics, even though such
persons have never shown signs of a neurotic conflict resulting in
symptoms. Thus one knows people with whom every human relationship ends
in the same way: benefactors whose protégés, however different they may
otherwise have been, invariably after a time desert them in ill-will, so
that they are apparently condemned to drain to the dregs all the
bitterness of ingratitude; men with whom every friendship ends in the
friend’s treachery; others who indefinitely often in their lives invest
some other person with authority either in their own eyes or generally,
and themselves overthrow such authority after a given time, only to
replace it by a new one; lovers whose tender relationships with women
each and all run through the same phases and come to the same end, and
so on. We are less astonished at this ‘endless repetition of the same’
if there is involved a question of active behaviour on the part of the
person concerned, and if we detect in his character an unalterable trait
which must always manifest itself in the repetition of identical
experiences. Far more striking are those cases where the person seems to
be experiencing something passively, without exerting any influence of
his own, and yet always meets with the same fate over and over again.
One may recall, for example, the story of the woman who married three
men in succession, each of whom fell ill after a short time and whom she
had to nurse till their death.[9] Tasso gives a singularly affecting
poetical portrayal of such a trend of fate in the romantic epic:
‘Gerusalemme liberata.’ The hero, Tancred, has unwittingly slain
Clorinda, the maiden he loved, who fought with him disguised in the
armour of an enemy knight. After her burial he penetrates into the
mysterious enchanted wood, the bane of the army of the crusaders. Here
he hews down a tall tree with his sword, but from the gash in the trunk
blood streams forth and the voice of Clorinda whose soul is imprisoned
in the tree cries out to him in reproach that he has once more wrought a
baleful deed on his beloved.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account