Biblical Revision: considerations in favour of a revised translation of Holy ScriptureSlater, Edward
Religion
Biblical Revision: considerations in favour of a revised translation of Holy Scripture
Slater, Edward
Bible -- Translating; Bible -- Versions
We have indeed said enough to justify our plea, and here we might close
the evidence, but we are tempted further to observe that the sense of
Scripture is not only obscured in the authorized version by errors of
translation, but there is almost an equal amount of mischief done to the
sense by the present mode of distributing the subject-matter into chapter
and verse; for which, as is well known, there is no valid authority,
{24a} either as regards the Old or the New Testament. This fault it is
the special object of the new Paragraph Bible lately published by the
Religious Tract Society, to remedy. We confine ourselves to two
illustrations.
The 53rd chapter of Isaiah begins with a parenthesis, (‘Who hath believed
our report, and to whom has the arm of the Lord been revealed?’) {24b}
This, in our view, is a _soliloquy_ into which the prophet breaks forth
in relief of his feelings, while contemplating the overpowering events
that pass in review before him, coupled with the rejection of the message
by the great body of his countrymen. {25a} These events had already
begun their career at the 13th verse of the foregoing chapter, and they
go steadily on through the remainder of that, and the whole of the
following chapter, broken only by the ejaculation of the prophet, thus
violently wrenched from its place, as the matter now stands.
The other instance we adduce of the obscuration of the sense occasioned
by the present faulty distribution of the letter-press, occurs Joshua v.
and vi. It is an example of an analogous kind to that already given. It
makes a parenthesis used simply in explanation of a series of
instructions from the Lord to Joshua to vacate its place in the
narrative, and actually stand at the commencement of a new chapter, in
which the same series of instructions is still continued. See the
“Edinburgh Review” for October last. {25b} We shall place the old and
new arrangement in juxta-position, when the violence done to the sense,
as the matter now stands, will be apparent at once.
_Old Arrangement_. _New Arrangement_.
Joshua v. 15.
And the captain of the Lord’s And the captain of the Lord’s
host said unto Joshua, Loose thy host said unto Joshua, “_Loose
shoe from off thy foot; for the thy shoe from off thy foot_, _for
place where thou standest _is_ the place where thou standest is
holy. And Joshua did so. holy_.” And Joshua did so.
Ch. vi. Now Jericho was straitly (Now Jericho was straitly shut
shut up, because of the children up, because of the children of
of Israel: none went out, and Israel; none went out, and none
none came in. came in). And the Lord said unto
Joshua, “_See_, _I have given
2. And the Lord said unto into thy hand Jericho_,” &c.
Joshua, See, I have given into
thy hand Jericho, &c.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account