Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecastBlacker, C. P. (Charles Paton)
Philosophy
Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecast
Blacker, C. P. (Charles Paton)
Birth control
2. An argument allied to the above, yet one which must be distinguished
carefully from it, deserves close scrutiny. It is to the effect that
quite apart from military considerations the practice of Birth Control
in a country is capable of acquiring in a short time such universality
that the population may decrease, and eventually dwindle to proportions
which would place that country, whatever its status, in a position of a
second or third-rate power. From history the approximate generalization
can be made that prolific races get the better of infertile races in
the struggle, first for existence, and then at a later stage, for
power. This generalization is likely to hold good in an economic
sphere. Thus a graphic picture has been drawn of what will happen to
England, in the matter of its population, if it follows in the wake
of France. It will come to assume the proportions of an insignificant
little island in the North Sea, the possessor, actually, of a mighty
past, but in the present counting for nothing beside the densely
peopled territories of Southern and Eastern Europe, Asia and America.
Birth Control uncontrolled means race suicide.
3. There is an ‘economic’ argument against Birth Control, which itself
takes two forms.
In the first place it is felt, in under-populated countries like New
Zealand, Australia, and perhaps to a less extent the United States,
that since it is desirable in the general interests that the population
should increase, it is to be preferred that this increase be effected
from native-born stock rather than through the process of accretion
by often undesirable aliens. Hence in most under-populated countries,
Birth Control is opposed.
In the second place it is probably felt (though probably not admitted)
by the Governments of those capitalistic countries confronted with
a labour problem, which are at the same time desirous of limiting
immigration, that the unrestricted multiplication of their working
classes, by causing a competition for wages, will create a cheap labour
market. It is highly unlikely that this view has much weight here,
though it may easily be otherwise in the United States, where the
labour problem is acute and where it is universally desired to limit
coloured immigration and immigration from South-Eastern Europe.
4. There is an argument against Birth Control, which has special
reference to the position of this country as the original founder of
a great Empire. Since most of the Dominions are still under-populated
and wish their numbers to increase, and since the increase of native
stock, even though fully encouraged, is unable to supply the demand for
labour, it is contended that Great Britain should always be able to
turn out a numerical surplus to send to the Dominions each year, which
in addition to satisfying a need for better-class immigrants would
serve to consolidate the racial and cultural bonds that keep the Empire
together.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account