Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecast — John Shaqi
Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecastBlacker, C. P. (Charles Paton)
Philosophy
Birth control and the state : $b A plea and a forecast
Blacker, C. P. (Charles Paton)
Birth control
B. The above arguments concern the race. The remainder which follow
refer primarily to the individual.
5. A ‘medical’ argument has been heard to the effect that the
actual practice of Birth Control or, more precisely, the use of
contraceptives, is inimical to health, being capable of causing both
local disease and more general constitutional disorders. Emotional
instability and various neuroses have been quoted as such products.
No woman making use of a contraceptive for the first time can escape
a feeling of revulsion at such a callous interference with a process
that above all others should be spontaneous and instinctive. No woman
can then fail to experience a sense of aversion from such a deliberate
thwarting of Nature’s most fundamental purpose.
6. Very potent also, is a ‘conventional’ objection which in practice
is often associated with the religious argument next to be considered,
though in reality it is distinguishable from it. On these grounds it
is felt that all that pertains to the province of sex is indecent,
disgusting, and unfit for discussion. The topic of Birth Control is
thus stigmatized as ‘immoral’ by many people of no deep religious
conviction.
7. The ‘religious’ objection nowadays finds its chief exponents among
the Japanese and Roman Catholics, though it is also strongly upheld by
many Anglicans and others. By the Japanese, Birth Control is condemned
on grounds that seem to be, partly at any rate, nationalistic. The
Japanese religion, intimately connected as it is with Ancestor Cult,
holds that it is the duty of every man to marry young, and to produce
the largest possible number of children, especially males, who may
carry on the tradition of the family and at the same time grow up into
soldiers capable of fighting for the Mikado in war. By the Japanese,
the Mikado is believed to be a Deity incarnate, not in the symbolical
sense in which some people have thought of the divine right of kings,
but in a real and vital sense, as ‘the occupant of a sacred throne
which was established at the time when the heavens and the earth
became separated.’ To die for him in war is the most supreme, the most
glorious duty. The objection to Birth Control here would thus seem
closely allied to the ‘military’ objection first advanced.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account