Shortly after the French revolution of February 1848, a Russian
diplomatic memoir was handed about with an air of mystery in certain
circles in Paris. M. de Bourgoing, formerly French minister at St
Petersburg, and author of a recent work, entitled, _Les guerres
d'idiome et de nationalité_, has published a commentary upon the
Russian memoir, which he tells us was prepared by one of the ablest and
best-informed employés in the Russian Chancellerie, after the events of
February. He further informs us that it was presented to the Emperor
of Russia, and, with the tacit consent of the Russian government, was
sent to be printed in a German capital, (the impression being limited
to twelve copies,) under the title of "_Politique et moyens d'action
de la Russie impartialement apprécié_." The object of M. Bourgoing's
commentary, as well as of his previous publication, appears to be
to remove exaggerated apprehensions of the aggressive power and
tendencies of Russia, and the fears of a general war in Europe, which
her anticipated intervention in Austria, and the occupation in force
of Wallachia and Moldavia by her troops, had excited in France. His
fundamental position appears to be, that the wars of 1848 and 1849
are essentially wars of language and race; that France has therefore
nothing to fear from them; and that Russia has neither a sufficient
disposable force, nor the slightest desire to interfere, in a manner
injurious to France, in the affairs of Western Europe. With this view
he combats, with a gentle opposition, the reasoning of the Russian
memoir, which he represents as "une déclaration où l'on est autorisé
à voir une espèce de manifeste envoyé sans éclat par la Russie à ce
qu'elle intitule la révolution." From the tendencies of M. Bourgoing's
writings, which occasionally peep out somewhat thinly clothed, though
they are generally well wrapped up, we should infer that the "ancien
ministre de France en Russie" does not consider his connexion with the
court of St Petersburg as finally terminated; and we do not doubt that
he has good warrant for all he says of the history of this memoir.
But, whether or not we may be disposed to assign to it a character
of so much authority as M. Bourgoing attributes to that document, we
cannot but regard it as a curious illustration of the kind of memoirs
that Russian diplomatists, "les plus habils et les plus instuits,"
present to the Emperor, and that the Russian government "tacitly
consents" to have transmitted to a German capital to be printed
"sur-le-champ."
The Russian memoir commences with the following general proposition,--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account