Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 75, No. 463, May, 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 75, No. 463, May, 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
We do not, however, quarrel with a poet for having an exalted idea of
his art—always supposing that he has taken any pains to acquire its
rudiments. Without a high feeling of this kind, it would be difficult to
maintain the struggle which must precede eminent success; nor would we
have alluded to the subject but for the affectation and offensive
swaggering of some who may indeed be rhymsters, but who never could be
poets even if their days were to be prolonged to the extent of those of
Methusaleh. When the painter of the tavern sign-post, whereon is
depicted a beer-bottle voiding its cork, and spontaneously ejecting its
contents right and left into a couple of convenient tumblers, talks to
us of high art, Raphael, and the effects of _chiaroscuro_, it is utterly
impossible to control the action of the risible muscles. And, in like
manner, when one of our young poetical aspirants, on the strength of a
trashy duodecimo filled with unintelligible ravings, asserts his claim
to be considered as a prophet and a teacher, it is beyond the power of
humanity to check the intolerable tickling of the midriff.
But, apart from their exaggerated notions of their calling, let us see
what is the practice of the poets of the Spasmodic School. In the first
place, they rarely, if ever, attempt anything like a plot. After you
have finished the perusal of their verses, you find yourself just as
wise as when you began. You cannot tell what they would be at. You have
a confused recollection of stars, and sunbeams, and moonbeams, as if you
had been staring at an orrery; but sun, moon, and stars, were intended
to give light to something—and what that something is, in the poet’s
page, you cannot, for the life of you, discover. In the second place, we
regret to say that they are often exceedingly profane, not, we suppose,
intentionally, but because they have not sense enough to see the limits
which decency, as well as duty, prescribes. In the third place, they are
occasionally very prurient. And, in the fourth place, they are almost
always unintelligible.
Now, although we cannot by any means aver that Mr Percy Jones is
entirely free from the faults which we have just enumerated, we look
upon him as a decidedly favourable specimen of his tribe. There is, in
_Firmilian_, if not a plot, at least some kind of comprehensible action;
and in it he has portrayed the leading features of the poetical school
to which he belongs with so much fidelity and effect, that we feel
called upon to give an outline of his tragedy, with a few specimens from
the more remarkable scenes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account