Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 93, No. 571, May, 1863Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 93, No. 571, May, 1863
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
What different impressions the same pictorial representation may convey
to two different persons, we have many an amusing instance of in the
history of our Egyptian discoveries, or efforts at discovery. We borrow
an example from the pages before us. On the wall of the temple at Philæ,
at the first cataract of the Nile, a figure is seen seated at work on
what seems a potter’s wheel, and there is a group of hieroglyphics over
its head. One learned translator reads and explains thus:—“Kaum the
Creator, on his wheel, moulds the divine members of Osiris (the type of
man) in the shining house of life, or the solar disk.” Another learned
man, Mr Birch of the British Museum, soars, if possible, still higher
for a meaning:—“Phtah Totonem, the father of beginnings, is setting in
motion the egg of the sun and moon, director of the gods of the upper
world.” Mr Wilson, we presume, in accordance with a still later
interpretation, calls this figure simply the “ram-headed god Kneph,”
without explaining what he is doing with his wheel. If the picture and
the hieroglyphic together lead to such various results, we may easily
conceive what wild work would be made by an attempt to interpret a
pictorial representation alone.
We hesitate to assign to the inscriptions discovered in these ruined
cities the true character of hieroglyphics; that is, of a system of
symbols by means of which, independently of oral tradition, the ideas of
one generation could be conveyed to another. But our readers would
probably prefer to have Mr Wilson’s matured judgment to our own
conjectures. He says:—
“On the sculptured tablets of Copan, Quirigua, and Palenque, as well
as on the colossal statues at Copan and other ancient sites in Central
America, groups of hieroglyphic devices occur arranged in
perpendicular or horizontal rows, as regularly as the letters of any
ancient or modern inscription. The analogies to Egyptian hieroglyphics
are great, for all the figures embody, more or less clearly defined,
representations of objects in nature or art. But the differences are
no less essential, and leave no room to doubt that in these columns of
sculptured symbols we witness the highest development to which
picture-writing attained, in the progress of that indigenous American
civilisation so singularly illustrative of the intellectual unity
which binds together the divers races of man. A portion of the
hieroglyphic inscription which accompanies the remarkable Palenque
sculpture of a figure offering what has been assumed to represent an
infant before a cross, will best suffice to illustrate the
characteristics of this form of writing.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account