Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 64, No. 393, July 1848 — John Shaqi
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 64, No. 393, July 1848Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 64, No. 393, July 1848
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
We have already seen how these results may be traced in the state
of French agriculture. They may also, we think, be discerned in the
relative position which the landholders of France bear to other
classes in the social scale. These, numbering between four and
five millions, ought, as a class, to constitute the leaders of the
nation. So far from this being the case, they are perhaps the most
inert and uninfluential portion of the community, having apparently
had little or no voice in the two revolutions which have swept over
their heads within the last eighteen years, and as little in the
erection, maintenance, or downfall of the Throne of the Barricades.
It yet remains to be seen whether they will continue to accept every
thing which the clubs of Paris are willing to force upon them. As
tax-payers and cultivators of the soil, it can hardly suit them to
be propagandists; as men who have something to lose, they will not
readily give in to the dictatorial vagaries of Ledru Rollin. If,
however, they would hold their own, it is time for them to be up and
doing. France has been governed by a minority before now.
We have always regarded it as one of the main advantages of a
landed aristocracy, that it raises up a principle of social rank
antagonistic to that of mere wealth. In France, the constant
subdivision and transfer of land breaks down this influence,
and causes land to be regarded as a mere marketable article and
equivalent for money.
"In countries where the custom of primogeniture exercises a
powerful influence, families become identified with estates--the
family representing the estate, and the estate the family. The
wealth and consideration enjoyed by the latter depend upon, and
are intimately connected with, the possession of the lands
which have descended to them from their ancestors. They estimate
their value by another than a mere pecuniary standard. They are
attached to them by the oldest and most endearing associations;
and they are seldom parted with except under the most painful
circumstances. Hence the perpetuity of property in England in
the same families, notwithstanding the limited duration of
entails; great numbers of estates being at this moment enjoyed
by those whose ancestors acquired them at or soon after the
Conquest. But in France such feelings are proscribed. Estates
and families have there no abiding connexion; and at the demise
of an individual who has a number of children, his estate can
hardly escape being subdivided. And this effect of the law tends
to imbue the proprietors with corresponding sentiments and
feelings. 'Non seulement,' says M. De Tocqueville, 'la loi des
successions rend difficile aux familles de conserver intacts les
mêmes domaines, mais elle leur òte le désir de le tenter, et
elle les entraîne, en quelque sorte, à coopérer avec elle à leur
propre ruine.'"--P. 85-86.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account