[19] Certain Soviets of Soldiers at the Front had decided that they would stay in their trenches for defensive purposes, but would obey no commands to go forward, no matter what the military situation. [20] Figures supplied by the Russian Information Bureau. [21] "It was with a deep and awful sense of the terrible failure before us that I consented to become Premier at that time," Kerensky told the present writer. [22] The story was reproduced in _New Europe_ (London), September, 1917. [23] _The New International_, April, 1918. [24] See p. 254. [25] See the letter of E. Roubanovitch, Appendix II, p. 331. [26] _Justice_, London, January 31, 1918. [27] _Justice_, London, May 16, 1918. [28] _Vide_ Special Memorandum to the International Socialist Bureau on behalf of the Revolutionary Socialist party of Russia. [29] See Appendix III. [30] _Pravda_, July 5, 1918. [31] February, 1918, Protest Against Recognition of Bolshevik Representative by British Labor Party Conference. [32] Proclamation to People of the Northern Province, etc., December, 1918 [33] _The New International_, April, 1918. [34] The dates given are according to the Russian calendar. [35] See the Rakitnikov Memorandum--Appendix. [36] _The New International_, April, 1918. [37] The number of votes was over 36,000,000. [38] _Vide_ Rakitnikov report. [39] Twenty-three members of the Executive Committee were arrested and, without any trial, thrown into the Fortress of Peter and Paul. [40] From a Declaration of Protest by the Executive Committee of the Third National Congress of Peasants' Delegates (anti-Bolshevist), sent to the Bolshevik Congress of Soviets of Workmen, Soldiers, and Peasants, but not permitted to be read to that assembly. [41] _L'Ouorier Russe_, May, 1918. [42] _Idem_. [43] _Izvestya_, July 28, 1918. [44] _Pravda_, October 8, 1918 (No. 216). [45] "Agents-Provocateurs and the Russian Revolution," article in _Justice,_, August 16, 1916, by J. Tchernoff. [46] Most of the information in this paragraph is based upon an article in the Swiss newspaper _Lausanne Gazette_ by the well-known Russian journalist, Serge Persky, carefully checked up by Russian Socialist exiles in Paris. [47] Joseph Martinek, in the _Cleveland Press_. [48] _Justice_ (London), January 23, 1919. [49] _Justice_, London, January 31, 1918. [50] Jean Jaures, _Studies in Socialism_. [51] F. Engels, 1895, Preface to Marx's _Civil War in France_. [52] The reader is referred to my _Sidelights on Contemporary Socialism_ and my _Karl Marx: His Life and Works_ for a fuller account of these struggles. [53] Marx, _A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy_, p. 12. [54] Editorial entitled "Bolshevik Problems," in _The Liberator_, April, 1918. [55] The article by Lenine quoted by Mr. Eastman appeared in _The New International_, February, 1918. [56] _The Bolsheviks and the Soviets_, by Albert Rhys Williams, p. 6.