American essays -- 19th century; Literature -- History and criticism
But for real and uncompromising severity towards children we must turn
to France, where for years the traditions of decorum and discipline
were handed down in noble families, and generations of boys and girls
suffered grievously therefrom. Trifling faults were magnified into
grave delinquencies, and relentlessly punished as such. We sometimes
wonder whether the youthful Bertrand du Guesclin were really the
wicked little savage that the old chroniclers delight in painting, or
whether his rude truculence was not very much like that of naughty
and neglected boys the world over. There is, after all, a pathetic
significance in those lines of Cuvelier’s which describe in barbarous
French the lad’s remarkable and unprepossessing ugliness:--
“Il n’ot si lait de Resnes à Disnant,
Camus estoit et noirs, malostru et massant.
Li père et la mère si le héoiant tant,
Que souvent en leurs cuers aloient desirant
Que fust mors, ou noiey en une eaue corant.”
Perhaps, if he had been less flat-nosed and swarthy, his better
qualities might have shone forth more clearly in early life, and it
would not have needed the predictions of a magician or the keen-eyed
sympathy of a nun to evolve the future Constable of France out of
such apparently hopeless material. At any rate, tradition generally
representing him either as languishing in the castle dungeon, or
exiled to the society of the domestics, it is plain he bore but slight
resemblance to the cherished _enfant terrible_ who is his legitimate
successor to-day.
Coming down to more modern times, we are met by such monuments of
stately severity as Madame Quinet and the Marquise de Montmirail,
mother of that fair saint Madame de Rochefoucauld, the trials of whose
later years were ushered in by a childhood of unremitting harshness
and restraint. The marquise was incapable of any faltering or weakness
where discipline was concerned. If carrots were repulsive to her little
daughter’s stomach, then a day spent in seclusion, with a plate of the
obnoxious vegetable before her, was the surest method of proving that
carrots were nevertheless to be eaten. When Augustine and her sister
kissed their mother’s hand each morning, and prepared to con their
tasks in her awful presence, they well knew that not the smallest
dereliction would be passed over by that inexorable judge. Nor might
they aspire, like Harriet Martineau, to shield themselves behind the
barrier of a lie. When from Augustine’s little lips came faltering some
childish evasion, the ten-year-old sinner was hurried as an outcast
from her home, and sent to expiate her crime with six months’ merciful
seclusion in a convent. “You have told me a falsehood, mademoiselle,”
said the marquise, with frigid accuracy; “and you must prepare to leave
my house upon the spot.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account