Cancer: Its Cause and Treatment, Volume 2 (of 2) — John Shaqi
Cancer: Its Cause and Treatment, Volume 2 (of 2)Bulkley, Lucius Duncan
Science
Cancer: Its Cause and Treatment, Volume 2 (of 2)
Bulkley, Lucius Duncan
Cancer
Realizing, then, that the mortality of cancer is materially and steadily
rising, in spite of most diligent research by innumerable honest and
capable scientists, with the expenditure of vast sums of money and
countless animal lives, and in spite of the work of ardent, earnest, and
capable surgeons, who have failed to stay the terrible progress of the
disease, let us briefly study some of the reported statistics in regard
to the results of operative interference in cancer.
It may be first stated that this is a most difficult task, so different
are the reports from different surgeons. There are many elements which
affect the statistics relating to the surgery of cancer. First of these
is, perhaps, the stage of the disease at which the operation is
performed. Second, the results vary, of course, immensely with the
knowledge and skill of the operator and the excellence of the technique.
Third, the class of cases operated on has much to do with favorable or
unfavorable results reported. Fourth, the length of observation after
operation is always to be considered in connection with surgical
statistics. Finally, the optimism of the reporter must be regarded in
weighing the true value of reports as to ultimate results. We will
briefly consider these points.
First, as to the stage of the disease at which the operation was
performed. We have seen in this and previous lectures that the lesion
which we call cancer is but a _result_ of a deranged blood state, and is
not a purely local process, a something simply to be removed surgically
in order to have the patient get well and remain well. For one sees
plenty of cases where there were recurrences even after the very
earliest operations possible. But the claims put forth that favorable
results are conditioned on very early operations are so strenuous and
persistent that we must believe that a measure of the favorable results
can be thus accounted for. We know, of course, that very late in the
disease operations are out of the question. It is a little curious,
however, that most of the pictures shown, statistics presented, and
arguments adduced by these ardent advocates of early operation relate to
cancer of the skin, especially about the face, which cause hardly 2 per
cent of all the deaths from cancer in various countries; whereas those
who see much of cutaneous epithelioma know that if properly handled it
is generally a comparatively mild affair and relatively easily cured
without surgical operation, as you have so constantly seen in this
clinic in past years. But mortality statistics are greatly influenced by
the class of cases which the operator takes, and so if epithelioma of
the skin is included, the ratio of cures will be high. Selected cases
also always give more favorable statistics.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account