Cancer: Its Cause and Treatment, Volume 2 (of 2)Bulkley, Lucius Duncan
Science
Cancer: Its Cause and Treatment, Volume 2 (of 2)
Bulkley, Lucius Duncan
Cancer
Second, the knowledge and skill of the operator and the perfection of
technique undoubtedly influence surgical statistics. The ordinary
practitioner or surgeon cannot hope for as favorable results in many
operations on cancer as can those who are past masters in this line, and
these latter are the ones who furnish the favorable statistics.
Third, the class of cases operated on affects surgical statistics very
greatly. While epithelioma of the face, and even of the lip, when well
removed, may yield most favorable statistics, cancer of the breast,
uterus, stomach, intestines, gall bladder, etc., yield increasingly
unfavorable statistics, as will be presently seen.
Fourth, the duration of observation after operation affects very
seriously the validity of statistics. Not long ago three years’ freedom
from disease was considered the time to regard a cancer as permanently
cured; but this time has been lengthened more and more, by the
observation of any number of cases where the disease has recurred even
long afterwards, and reliable observers are now very chary in expressing
an opinion as to the final cure of a cancer. This will be more fully
considered in another lecture.
Finally, the optimism of the reporter seems often to have something to
do with the reliability of surgical statistics. This need hardly be
discussed. The older and more experienced the surgeon the less confident
he is of having actually cured cancer with the knife. At a discussion in
the New York Academy of Medicine, some years ago, Dr. Robert F. Weir
said that the late Dr. Agnew, a celebrated surgeon of Philadelphia, had
remarked, just before his death, that he doubted if he had ever been
justified in an operation upon cancer, and he, Dr. Weir, stated that he
could almost say the same.
Turning now to the actual statistics of operative surgery on cancer, we
will find that the percentage of reported cures varies very greatly, in
accordance with the points just stated. It is understood, of course,
that no accurate statements can be made from statistics in reference to
the actual mortality of cancer in any location, partly owing to the
paucity of figures, and partly because the stages and extent of the
disease differ so greatly, and the results vary with the previous
duration of the lesion and the period of observation after the
operation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account