Character of Renaissance ArchitectureMoore, Charles Herbert
History
Character of Renaissance Architecture
Moore, Charles Herbert
Architecture, Renaissance
“ ... Murinsi la cupola nel modo di sopra, senz’ alcuna armadura,
massime insino a braccia 30; ma da indi in su, in quel modo che
sarà consigliato e deliberato per quei maestri che l’avranno a
murare: perchè nel murare la pratica insegna quello che si ha da
seguire.”--Guasti, _La Cupola di Santa Maria del Fiore_, Florence,
1857, pp. 28–30.
[14] Durm, _Die Dom Kuppel in Florenz_, etc., Berlin, 1887, Plate
I, gives an admirable illustration of the internal system of this
remarkable dome, and shows the masonry of the solid base with its
clamps and chains, as described in the document quoted by Guasti (note,
p. 18).
[15] This idea finds expression in the latest work that I have seen
on the subject: _Die Kuppel des Domes Santa Maria del Fiore zu
Florence_. Von Paul Wenz, Berlin, 1901, p. 52; also in Durm, _Die
Baukunst der Renaissance in Italien_, p. 406.
[16] For a full account of the deliberations held, as well as for much
else of importance relating to the building of this dome, see Professor
C. E. Norton’s _Church Building in the Middle Ages_, New York,
Harper & Brothers, 1880.
[17] But while Brunelleschi appears to have had great natural
constructive aptitude, he had not had a sound training or experience
in construction. Such training would have taught him that it would not
do, under any circumstances, to spring a vault from the top of a wall,
and he ought to have learned this from his study of the ancient Roman
monuments.
[18] Nelli, _Discorsi di Architettura_, Florence, 1753, p.
74, reproduces an old drawing which purports to show the form of
the scaffolding that Brunelleschi employed. This drawing bears the
following inscription: “Questa Dimostrazione è di Filippo Brunelleschi
Architetto fatta per e Ponti della Cupola di S. M’ra. del Fiore di
Firenze nell’Anno M.CCCCXIX e fu quella che mostrò quando fu lasciato
in libertà di dover esser solo nell’operazione di d.^a cupola senza il
Ghiberti suo compagno non avendola voluta dar fuori prima di non essere
libero Architetto di d^a Opera; come sentiranno nella sua Vita scritta
da Diversi.” Brunelleschi, in his account of his intentions before the
Board of Works (note, p. 19), would not explain his scheme for the
scaffolding. He said merely that the vault was to be raised, without
centring, to the height of 30 braccia, and from that level upwards, in
the manner that should be advised by those who might then have the work
in charge.
[19] In his explanation of his scheme before the Board of Works, as
given by Vasari, Brunelleschi begins as follows: “Considerato le
difficultà di questa fabbrica, magnifici Signori Operaj, trovo che non
si può per nessun modo volgerla tonda perfetta, atteso che sarebbe
tanto grande il piano di sopra, dove va la lanterna, che mettendovi
peso rovinerebbe presto.” _Op. cit._, vol. 2, p. 347.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account