Children's Ways: Being selections from the author's "Studies of childhood," with some additional matterSully, James
Science
Children's Ways: Being selections from the author's "Studies of childhood," with some additional matter
Sully, James
Child development; Child psychology
At first nothing seems clearer than the evidence of malevolent intention
in a child's treatment of animals. A little girl when only a year old
would lift two kittens by the neck and try to stamp on them. Older
children often have a way of treating even their pets with a similar
roughness.
Yet I think we cannot safely say that such rough usage is intended to be
painful. It seems rather to be the outcome of the mere energy of the
childish impulse to hold, possess, and completely dominate his pet.
The case of destructive cruelty, as when a small boy crushes a fly, is
somewhat different. Let me give a well-observed instance. A little boy
of two years and two months, "after nearly killing a fly on the
window-pane, seemed surprised and disturbed, looking round for an
explanation, then gave it himself: 'Mr. Fly dom (gone) to by-by'. But he
would not touch it or another fly again--a doubt evidently remained, and
he continued uneasy about it." Here the arrest of life clearly brought a
kind of shock, and we may safely say was not thought out beforehand.
Children may pounce upon and maul small moving things for a number of
reasons. The wish to gratify their sense of power--which is probably
keener in children who so rarely gratify it than in grown-ups--will
often explain these actions. To stop all that commotion, all that
buzzing on the window-pane, by a single tap of the finger, that may
bring a delicious thrill of power to a child. Curiosity, too, is a
powerful incentive to this kind of maltreatment of animals. Children
have something of the anatomist's impulse to take living things apart,
to see where the blood is, as one child put it, and so forth.
I think, then, that we may give the small offenders the benefit of the
doubt, and not attribute their rough handling of animals to a wish to
inflict pain, or even to an indifference to pain of which they are
clearly aware. Wanton activity, the curiosity of the experimenter, and
delight in showing one's power and producing an effect, seem sufficient
to explain a large part of the unlearned brutality of the first years.
We have now looked at one of the darkest sides of the child and have
found that though it is decidedly unpleasant it is not quite so ugly as
it has been painted. Children are no doubt apt to be greedy, and
otherwise unsociable, to be ferocious in their anger, and to be sadly
wanting in consideration for others; yet it is some consolation to
reflect that their savageness is not quite that of brutes, and that
their selfishness and cruelty are a long way removed from a deliberate
and calculating egoism.
_The Promise of Humanity._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account