Education, Higher; Students -- United States; Universities and colleges -- United States
By the other group, college is recalled as a waste of time. The
transition from the position of a kept and protected favorite child
into that of a grown man under the imperative of having to earn his
own keep has worked a disillusionment. Instead of getting the job he
believes his degree entitles him to, he finds himself a superfluity in
the labor market. Employers are likely to speak of him as bumptious,
immature, undeveloped, a cub. He finds, even for the simplest tasks,
either that he must unlearn what he has learned, or, if he is lucky,
that he has no training at all. He begins to regret his college life
and to consider that college has failed him. Thinking about it, as did
Philip Wylie, he realizes that “the serious purpose” of college not
only was not serious to him, but could not have been. For, as the New
York boy found already in high school, the curriculum offers him no
momentous living option. The subject matter is irrelevant to all that
is dynamic in him, it lacks vital links with both the passions of his
heart and the actual world where, after college, he must live and move
and have his being. It is presented mostly by persons to whom teaching
is as much a disagreeable penalty for the amenities of “scholarly” life
as learning is to the student for the amenities of college life. Hence,
the student seeks to pay the minimum penalty, which is to pass his
examination by any means whatsoever. Sometimes the disillusion rises
during undergraduate years. Then there are editorials in the college
papers. Administrations are criticized, professors are graded, courses
are scored, abuses are denounced. Deans and faculties squirm and are
glad when the student interest in education subsides. Fortunately
such bursts of interest are rare interludes. For the most part, it is
faculties, not students, who are agitated about education.
And why should students be agitated about anything still so monastic,
that isolates nearly all of those who enter upon it from the realities
among which they expect to spend their lives, and sustains them in a
state of irresponsibility and irrelevance? At an age when body and mind
cry out against infancy, “the higher education” prolongs infancy; it
sets up and maintains a conflict between psychobiological adulthood and
social childishness. In this conflict “college life” has its fertile
soil. It nourishes all those psychological expressions which fall
into the patterns of undergraduate attitudes and behavior that are
designated by the word “collegiate.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account