Education, Higher; Students -- United States; Universities and colleges -- United States
The secondary school and the college are by tradition and practice
instruments pat to the social postponement of adulthood and the
prolongation of social infancy.
By and large, only those children enter high school who do not need
to work for a living. They enter about the time that children of
the residual world enter life, at puberty. Their attending high
school signalizes an invidious distinction between them and their
contemporaries, for the high school has been from its beginning a mark
of “aristocracy.” Even the “commercial” high school, which is yet of
low esteem beside the high school preparing for college, celebrates
this invidious distinction. But the real McCoy is the “college
preparatory.” College sits _in excelsis_. The topmost turn of the
educational system, it sets the standards and defines the ideal both of
knowledge and conduct. Secondary-school students consequently prepare
for college in a far completer way than is recognized. They emulate
and reproduce the whole pattern and structure of “college life,” with
its fraternities and other societies, its athletics, its hidden sex
interests, and all the rest. Indeed, since the “educative process”
worked by the schools is defined from above downward, the colleges,
which are for the most part resorts where the well-to-do keep their
physiologically mature young in a state of personal irresponsibility
and social-economic dependence, set the standard of education for the
whole nation.
Practice under this standard maintains a gulf between the curriculum
and student interests. The school work, as the teacher sees it, makes
up the “serious purpose” for which schools and colleges exist. Yet here
is what a boy who believes in this serious purpose writes to the _New
York Times_ about his education:
“In a few weeks I will be handed a diploma, have my hand shaken by
sundry individuals, and then told that I have been graduated from
high school. I am supposed to be educated. The city has provided me
for some four years with skilled teachers and expensive apparatus and
told me, ‘Be conscientious in your studies and you shall know.’ I
know that I have been sincere, but I will tell a few things I do not
know.
“I know by heart several slices of Shakespeare and Browning, but
I do not know how to write an ordinary form letter that would be
accepted by any business firm. I know some irregular French verbs but
if I were lost in the streets of Paris I would not be able to ask my
way home. I can, ‘amo, amas, amat,’ also ‘en to oikio ton anthropon
horo,’ but I cannot keep the ledger in my father’s place of business
nor send out his monthly statements. I am a member of the tennis team
and know all the quirks and tricks used in hitting a tennis ball, but
I do not know how to build a woodshed nor shingle a roof.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account