Let us imagine an Infinite Plane, placed upright, and facing us—as
if we were standing in front of a wall, which extended to infinity,
upwards, downwards, to the right-hand, and to the left. If we divide
this Plane by a single horizontal straight Line, extended to infinity
to the right-hand and to the left, we get half of the whole
Plane above the Line, and half below it, wherever
we choose to place the Line. This may be deduced from the logical
principle that we have no reason for believing either to be
greater than the other; or we may adopt M. Bertrand's Axiom, "Two
spaces, whether finite or infinite, are equal, when one can be placed
upon the other so that any point whatsoever of either coincides with a
point of the other"—a condition which seems, theoretically, readily
attainable, by making one portion of the Plane revolve round the
boundary-line, as a hinge, till it coincides with the other portion.
Each portion is, of course, an Infinity of the same order as the
whole Plane.
Now let us imagine two such infinite horizontal straight Lines,
'separational' from each other (i. e. never intersecting), placed at
a finite distance apart, and therefore having between them a Strip,
finite in width, infinite in length, and therefore infinite in area.
Now it clearly is not possible, by multiplying this Infinite
Strip by any finite number, however great, to make it exceed, or even
equal, the whole Infinite-Plane. Here again, then, Euclid's test fails,
and neither of these Magnitudes, though they are homogeneous can
be said to have a 'Ratio' to the other.[Pg 44] In fact, the Infinite-Strip is
an Infinity of a lower order than the Infinite-Plane.
Comparing this Strip with a single square-inch, you will, I fancy,
be willing to grant at once that no multiple of the latter
can possibly reach—much less exceed—the former. We have, in fact,
established the existence of three kinds of Area, viz. Finite
Areas (e.g. a square inch), Infinities of the first order (e.g. the
Infinite-Strip we have been considering), and Infinities of the second
order (e.g. the upper half of the whole Infinite-Plane).
Now let us go a step further. Let the two sides of this Strip be
supposed to gradually approach each other—still maintaining their
'separational' character—and let us consider the effect of this
process on the intervening area.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account